2014 Last Stand and Everglades Law Center water quality symposium in Key West report


Depress ctrl and + keys together to increase zoom/font size; depress ctrl and – keys together to reduce

Right now, most of what I publish daily is at www.goodmorningkeywest.com, which you should be able to reach by clicking on that link. That’s because I live down there now and am running for mayor. Sometimes I put something new on this website, too.

This past Tuesday night, I attended a water quality symposium at Eco-Discovery in Key West, co-hosted by Last Stand and Everglades Law Center

Here’s the Key West Citizen report on the symposium:

Wednesday, April 23, 2014 Add to Facebook Add to Twitter
Everglades restoration will benefit Keys, say experts

Experts in the field of water quality and coral reef ecology made their case Tuesday night why major ongoing Everglades restoration projects will benefit the Florida Keys environmentally and economically.

The Florida Keys environmental group Last Stand and the Everglades Law Center scheduled two public forums in the Keys this week to better explain the importance of the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Project.

The panel of experts gave an overview of how the Everglades restoration projects will bring more and cleaner fresh water into Florida Bay, benefitting Keys waters, “one of the most biologically diverse ecosystems in the Caribbean,” said panel member and National Marine Sanctuaries Program Regional Administrator Billy Causey.

Decades of water management policies redirected the natural flow of fresh waters away from the southern end of the Everglades and Florida Bay, essentially to benefit the agriculture industry and residential development in South Florida. Those practices led to a collapse of Florida Bay and its seagrass ecosystems in the early 1990s, as half of its fresh water influx was removed, said panel member Tom Van Lent, director of science and policy for the Everglades Foundation.

State and federal government projects to fix the water flow began in the early 2000s, and continue today.

The road to Everglades recovery must include more clean fresh water; remove barriers to natural water flow; and restore the historical flow, Van Lent said.

One of the biggest Army Corps of Engineers projects currently ongoing is the Central Everglades Planning Project, which will restore the flow of water across hundreds of acres in the center of the Everglades, according to Van Lent’s presentation.

“It’s not as easy to put it back to what it was, but that is Everglades restoration,” Van Lent said. “It won’t heal itself.”

Florida Bay encompasses the Upper Keys backcountry waters, and is frequented by nearly all of the Upper Keys flats and backcountry fishing guides.

The ocean, reefs and backcountry waters off the Keys alone generate more than $140 million a year directly through fishing and diving, according to NOAA statistics.

The Florida Keys is also the highest grossing commercial seafood hub in the state, in terms of revenue, and third largest in the country, bringing in more than $100 million a year, according to the Florida Keys Commercial Fishermen’s Association.

For every $1 the government puts towards Everglades restoration, there is a $4 return to the South Florida economy, said panel member Jerry Lorenz, Audubon of Florida’s director of research at its Tavernier Science Center.

Lorenz, who actively conducts bird and fish counts in the Everglades and Florida Bay, argued that the health of key species of commercially and recreationally fished marine life — such as spiny lobster, stone crab, redfish and snook — depend on healthy water flows out of the Everglades and into Florida Bay and the Keys.

“It’s not just about the ecosystem, it’s about the economy,” Lorenz said. “This is what we sell. This is what we are.”


I saw Tim leave the auditorium during the symposium. Or perhaps he went to the bathroom and came back into the auditorium and I did not see him return. Perhaps while Tim was away was when the Everglades Law Center lawyer informed Billy Causey and the scientists that the Army Corps of Engineers, earlier yesterday, had announced they will not participate in restoring the flow of water into the Everglades. The scientists’ sighs of disappointment were intense.

Here’s my report on the symposium:

Billy CauseyBilly Causey

I learned lots about Everglades history and nitrates and phosphates and corals. I learned coral reefs have been declining world-wide for some time, and the main cause seems to be global warming. I was not persuaded, however, by Billy Causey’s comment that nitrates and chemicals are not why much of our reef died off, because, Causey said, there is no evidence those chemicals ever reached our reef. The scientists, who spoke behind Causey, said phosphates and nitrates are bad for coral, sea grass, etc. And, a chart  Causey put up on the screen showed some nitrates and phosphates on the reef

Causey and the scientists focused heavily on too much salinity in Florida Bay caused by the lack of normal freshwater flow out of the Everglades. And on sewerage pollution coming off the Florida Keys. And on global warming.

Brian LaPoint, PhD was not there – he might have had a stroke and dropped dead. His view is nitrates are what killed most of our reef, and nitrates are still coming down here from the mainland, through Florida Bay. Brian’s satellite photos of that happening, which he presented in a slide show to the Key West City Commission maybe two months ago, at the request of City Commissioner Jimmy Weekley, were shocking and compelling. I felt Causey’s remarks were aimed dead and LaPointe, without saying so. I felt LaPoint should have been there, to provide his view. I tried to get Last Stand to do that, and was not successful. Cause told me after the symposium, after I told him that LaPoint first had schooled me, that that was my problem. I told Causey he is the problem.

That aside, Causey and the scientists and the environmental lawyer are on the right track saying the water flow through the Everglades needs to be restored. No kidding. Blocking the natural flow of water through the Glades was what screwed up the Glades and Florida Bay, which became more saline after much of the fresh water stopped going through the Glades into Florida Bay. One of the scientists said they hope to be able to restore 80 percent of the original water flow into the Glades, and to reestablish the old southward central water-flow pathway into Florida Bay near the Florida Keys.

The speakers said a great deal of water now is being jettisoned out of Lake Okeechobee into an east-west canal, through which the water heads to the west and east coasts of Florida and comes into Florida Bay far to the west. It was said the people on the east and west coasts are Florida are furious about all that water being dumped on them, large street protests against that water have happened. Not said last night was why the east and west Floridians are furious about receiving that dirty water.

After the meeting ended, I asked the lady lawyer if she had interviewed the people on the east and west coasts about why they are so upset about that water being sent to them from Lake Okeechobee? She said she had interviewed them. I said, then she knows they are up in arms over that water being dirty, full of nitrates and phosphates, which kill the sea grasses the manatees eat, and cause the red weed (algae, the red tide algae) to blossom. Losing their food source, the manatee starve. They eat the red weed, which is poisonous to them. They get sick, then they die.

The lady lawyer said, yes, that is happening. I said I wished they had told the audience that. For that is the same water they want to bring from Lake Okeechobee down through the Everglades into Florida Bay. Of course, that water must be cleaned up, before it can be released into the Glades. That’s why the dirty water had been diverted from the Everglades years ago, into Lake Okeechobee, because it was damaging the Glades and Florida Bay. The lady lawyer agreed, and said the scientists have designed a filter system, which they had hardly explained, after I told them from my seat that the filter system is critical, the most important thing, which they hope will clean up that dirty water. She said the dirty water cannot be allowed into the Glades.

I thought Causey had said during the meeting that Okeechobee water released through the Glades would be cleaned up by the time it reached Florida Bay. And I thought one of the scientists had said the dirty water had to be cleaned before it reached the Glades, because it would not be cleaned by passing through the Glades. Brian LaPoint told me a year ago that the dirty water would not be cleaned up by passing through the Glades. He also told me about the dirty water’s effect on the manatees on the east and west coasts, and how it grew a lot more red weed.

Brian La PointeLaPoint

If I had not been schooled by LaPoint, I would not have known about the manatee dying, I would not have known of the dirty water coming out of Lake Okeechobee.

After speaking with the lady lawyer, I found Causey and covered most of that same ground with him. Then, I said, Governor Scott is up for reelection this year. His opponent, Charlie Crist, is an environmentalist, or so is said. The Republicans very much want Scott to be reelected this year. The Keys low number of voters is meaningless to Governor Scott. The east and west coast of Florida voter numbers are great, probably in the millions. Governor Scott wants to stop those east and west coast Floridians from demonstrating against that dirty water being sent to them and killing their manatees, but the Army Corps of Engineers wants to keep killing all those manatees and doesn’t want the restore the natural water flow though the Everglades! Imagine what FOX News CNN would do with that!

I told Causey that where he lives, on Big Pine Key, bio-hazard grinder pumps are widely being installed. Causey said he didn’t know about that situation. I said it is a big problem, and he should be all over it. I had told him the same thing maybe three months ago in the Marathon Government Center during a Marine Sanctuary meeting on polluted Florida Keys canals.

I then covered much the same ground, except for grinder pumps, with the scientists, one at a time.

When I told the last scientist that it looks to me their only mission is to try to get the water turned back on into the Glades, and to make sure that water is clean, he said they have only one valve they can turn, and that is the valve bringing all that water going east-west back down through the Glades. I said, I sure do hope they will be able to clean up that dirty water. He said he thinks they will will be able do it. That’s a heck of a lot of dirty water running out of Lake Okeechobee into that east-west canal, and then to the east and west Florida coasts.

I sat beside Al Sullivan during the presentation last night. Al used to be President of Last Stand. I said all day I was feeling something toxic coming into me, making me feel lousy, and I couldn’t figure out what it was, because I didn’t see anything concerning Key West, which would have that effect on me yesterday. And now here I was in the water quality symposium, seeing and hearing about what was making me feel so bad.

cruise ship truth 2

photo taken last year by Jolly Benson’s brother Will, a Key West tarpon guide, of cruise ship leaving Key West

Sitting on the other side of me last night was William Benson, Jolly Benson’s father. Jolly led the charge to defeat the bigger cruise ships calling on Key West referendum last year. William asked me what did I think the lady lawyer, Causey and the scientists felt about dirty cruise ships? I said I doubt they have any interest in that, I brought cruise ships up in Marathon a few months ago, and Causey looked at me like I was a lunatic. That might have been due to my also having quoted Brian LaPointe during my citizen comments.

psychiatrist interviews

Jerry Weinstock, M.D., Psychiatry, retired (sort of), also environtmanal activist, living in Key Haven just above Key West, wrote to me yesterday:

Sloan: the water quality in our canal was healthy, clear,
clean, full of marine sea life —-that is a span of
over 30 years. When the Cruise polluters arrived it
deteriorated rapidly, fiercely, perversely, into a
nightmarish horrible smelly unhealthy mess.
That is indisputable fact. regards—Jerry

Sloan Bashinsky

Sloan at Coco's


4/25/2014 Post-Script”

cracked egg

When I left Last Stand and Everglades Law Center’s water quality symposium Tuesday night, I felt a huge disturbance in the Force. I was really upset, too. As time passed, the unrest continued to torment me, and I continued to feel a great disturbance in the Force.

asteroid belt

Yesterday afternoon, out of the blue, something came to me. I didn’t like seeing it, but it created a shift inside of me and I felt myself moving through the torment, into a really sober state of being.

Perhaps some history is needed, before I get down to the bones.

When I first learned of the water quality symposium from Last Stand’s President Naja Girard, to be held at Eco Discovery Center on Truman Waterfront last Tuesday night, I wrote to Naja asking if Dr. Brian LaPointe, a Big Pine Key part-time resident,

Brian La PointeLa Pointe

would be one of the presenters? Naja replied that he would not be there, his views were widely known and he had recently presented them at a KW city commission meeting. I wrote back that I was not happy to hear that, please invite Dr. LaPointe to also present at the water quality symposium. He was not invited.

As I wrote in the recent  2014 Last Stand and Everglades Law Center water quality symposium in Key West report  post at www.goodmorningfloridakeys.com, Billy Causey, of the Marine Sanctuary, a Big Pine Key resident,

Billy CauseyCausey

without naming LaPointe, told the water quality symposium audience that there is no evidence phosphates and nitrates ever reached our reef. LaPoint’s view is that is exactly what happened, and that was the heart of his compelling slide show presentation to the KW City Commission. Had LaPointe been at the water quality symposium, he would have disputed Causey’s remark. Had LaPointe been at the water quality symposium, the audience would have gotten a far different perspective.

As I wrote in the  2014 Last Stand and Everglades Law Center water quality symposium in Key West report  post at www.goodmorningfloridakeys.com, I felt Causey made a couple misstatements of fact during the symposium.

La Pointe would have disagreed with Causey saying diry water could be released into the Everglades and it would be cleaned up by the time it reached Florida Bay. LaPointe would have explained the havoc that dirty water would wreak in the Everglades en route to Florida Bay.

Causey doesn’t agree with LaPointe. Causey told me that himself after the symposium ended. Causey told me that’s where I went wrong, listening to LaPointe. Maybe Causey would not have participated in the water quality symposium, if LaPointe had been there. Maybe the scientists would not have been there, if LaPointe had been there.

My take was, at the symposium, without saying he was doing it, Causey attacked La Pointe, by saying there was no evidence of nitrates and phosphates having reached our reef, which Causey did not tell the audience was LaPointe’s position. Yet the a chart Causey put up on the screen showed nitrates and phosphates on the reef. One of the scientists said that coral reefs grow where there are no nutrients.

LaPointe told me about a year a go that the chemicals reached our reef years ago; killed about 90 percent of the reef. He showed the City Commission that the chemicals are still being dumped into Florida Bay, mostly on its west side, and those chemicals are making their way down to us and our reef.

Now for the woo woo part of this report.

During the symposium, the Everglades Law Center’s lawyer informed the scientists and the audience, perhaps Causey already knew of it, that the Army Corps of Engineers earlier that same day had announced they would not go along with bringing more water into the Everglades, which was the entire thrust of the Marine Sanctuary, Causey and the scientists’ presentation, and the only possible cure for what ails the Everglades, high salinity in Florida Bay, and the downstream effect of that on our reef. The scientists were visibly and audibly distressed to to hear that awful news at the symposium.

Years ago I also learned about timing, which some people call synchronicity. The timing of the Corps’ decision not to participate on the same day as the water quality control symposium put on by Last Stand and the Everglades Law Center, without LaPointe being there, is all one bundle; all one downstream event, dating back to my attempt to get Naja to include LaPointe in the symposium, and she declined.

Perhaps if a second water quality symposium is held in Key West and on Key Largo, which includes LaPointe, that will take care of the disturbance in the Force and help get the Army Corps of Engineers involved. The scientists will have to convince the Corps, though, that their filter system will clean up the dirty water before it is released into the Everglades.

Before thinking to yourself that Sloan finally went over the edge and around the bend, consider that some years ago now, Naja told me that she felt she had exhausted all avenues re proving the Navy, not the Bernsteins, owned Wisteria Island, which lies a few hundred yards to the west of Key West’s Old Town section.

Wisteria Island

I then dreamed that Naja needed to keep digging, there was something she had not found. I told her about the dream, said it was the angels’ way of telling me to tell her to keep digging. She kept digging and found something, which she presented it to the Department of the Interior, Bureau of Land Management and US Fish and Wildlife, and the Feds, after some initial balking, agreed with Naja that the US Government owned Wisteria Island. The Bureau publicly stated their claim, and then the Bernsteins filed suit in a federal court on the mainland to try to get that undone. That lawsuit was tried quite a while ago and as of yet the federal judge has not rendered an opinion.

How the lawsuit turns out is not the point. The point is, Wisteria Island was given to me by the angels who run me, for me to engage with other people. Naja was one of those other people. She did her part, and then some, which now has the title question before a federal judge, as per Arnaud’s editorial cartoon in one of last year’s blue paper issues. Can you pick out Naja and Arnaud in the cartoon? Hint – look for a seaman with a patch over one eye. That’s Roger Bernsteain, a Miami tax lawyer, on the left, his lawyer beside him, glaring over at the good guys.

Naja told me the judge and Bernstein’s lawyer are old friends. The judge must be a bit strained – hope he let’s it get to him on the side of the good guys.

Wisteria trial

In today’s Citizen – www.keysnews.com – is a report of the Monroe County Commission resisting yet another attempt by the Bernsteins to get Wisteria Island specially designated so they can put hotels and condos on it like what happened on its gauche neighbor, Tank Island, now called Sunset Key.

Wisteria & Sunset

What was Monroe County thinking, even considering the Bernsteins’ recent attempt, when title to Wisteria Island is tied up in a U.S. District Court on the mainland? How much county staff time, which translates to dollar$, was wasted by the county government even spending one second on the Bernsteins’ latest attempt, when the Bernsteins do not know who owns the island? Or do they? Has the federal judge told his lawyer friend how he will rule on the title?

By the way, all along, the Bernsteins’ field general for turning Wisteria into Sunset Key Deux was Jim Hendrick, who is the Peary Court developer’s field general, and Pritam Singh’s field general. The same Jim Hendrick who used to be the Monroe County Attorney, who eventually was charged, tried and convicted in federal court for conspiracy and witness tampering stemming from allegations he had, when he was County Attorney, facilitated a bribe of a county commissioner by a developer. By the time the US Attorney got involved, the statute of limitations had run on the bribery charge, but not on the conspiracy and witness tampering charges. Hendrick was disbarred and put on a strict probation for quite a while. During which time he did everything he did when he was a lawyer, but go to court. I know that, because I heard him tell someone that.

About Sloan

That's what this website is about, also goodmorningkeywest.com and goodmorningbirmingham.com. If you can't get a publisher to take on your wacky musing, you do it yourself.
This entry was posted in Today's FlaKey Drivel. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply