Archive for December, 2011

cruise ship and school district distractions

Saturday, December 31st, 2011

Two articles in The Citizen today (keysnews.com) caught my attention.

One article is about the resurrection of the channel-widening study for much bigger cruise ships, which makes no mention of the environment and focuses on the business side of it and conflicts of interests three city commissioners seem to have because their businesses receive considerable revenue from cruise ships. Also, City Commissioner Tony Yaniz is quoted as saying Chamber of Commerce members have told him they fear speaking out against the channel widening because of threats of retaliation to their businesses if they do so. The Chamber was reported in a recent article in The Citizen as strongly in favor of the channel widening. The fear some have stated is, if the channel is not widened, when the much bigger cruise ships come online, Key West will lose its cruise ship business because the new ships will be unable to get into Key West’s harbor. On behalf of Mother Nature and her citizens, I simply offer this photo as proof Key West should not entertain even the small monster cruise ships now calling there:

Here is the other article that caught my attention:

Jara: Booker is target of second probe

Administrator says she’s being singled out by the district

BY GWEN FILOSA Citizen Staff

gfilosa@keysnews.com

The superintendent of the Monroe County School District said Friday he is further investigating the work of 11-year-veteran employee Sunny Booker as part of a review of whether high school students received more make-up credits than allowed.

“We can’t tolerate relaxed behavior around this process,” said Jesus Jara, who said the inquiry into Booker’s handling of a June graduation party for at-risk students is over — but that a second investigation that involves Booker is weeks under way.

“This is a bigger issue,” Jara said of his questions about the administration of EdOptions, an online “credit retrieval” program that allows students who have failed a course to make up the credits via the computer.

Jara said the district is looking into EdOptions use at several high schools, but that the alternative school where Booker was principal until a few months ago raised the first red flag.

In response, Booker said the district is singling her out after failing to find any wrongdoing over a graduation party she put on for her students at the alternative school.

“Why are they trying to destroy me?” Booker asked rhetorically on Friday, the first time she has spoken publicly since the School District leveled formal administrative charges against her in September. “I am a year-to-year contract person. There is no reason for all of this. I’ve worked 12 years with exemplary evaluations.”

Booker, whose career spans 21 years, including a decade before she came to the Florida Keys, said, “I’m a very hard worker. I have brought in a ton of money for the district.”

Since the initial complaints by the district accused her of misconduct, Booker has referred all questions to her attorney, Robert Cintron. But on Friday, she spoke out, questioning the motives behind Jara’s investigations.

Booker said she was written up for following the direction of the district’s auditors, who confirmed that she took their advice of not opening a personal account for the party.

The now-dispensed allegations, over the financial handling of a $1,200 graduation party luncheon Booker organized for her students at the alternative school, Academic Connections for Excellence, ended with a written reprimand by Superintendent Jara, dated Nov. 15, and not released by the district.

The June luncheon for ACE students was attended by School Board Vice Chairman Andy Griffiths, a keynote speaker for the program, board Chairman John Dick, along with then-superintendent Joe Burke.

ACE at the time had no internal accounts, preventing the school from holding fundraisers, Booker said. So she sought guidance from the district auditor and internal auditor Ken Gentile, and had luncheon guests pay $23 a plate, while accepting a total of $600 in donations from the Rotary Club and a colleague, and ponying up $500 herself for the rest of the lunch, decorations and certificates.

“I’m out $800,” Booker said Friday, adding that she has paid back $300 to teacher Sandy Ashwell, who provided a replacement check after Booker told her she had lost the first one, which was made out to Salute and deposited in the restaurant’s account after Booker endorsed it.

Jara said Friday that he had intended to release the Nov. 15 reprimand when the entire investigation was complete. For a month now, he said, the district has been reviewing whether students at the ACE school received too many credits in a year through EdOptions.

“We can’t use credit retrieval as the savior,” said Jara. “Why are kids not succeeding in the regular classrooms and sitting in front of a computer?”

In essence, the credit retrieval process is costing taxpayers double, he said.

The district’s investigation into possible extra credits cropped up from another investigation into why administrators signed off on a contract with EdOptions before receiving the required approval from the School Board.

“We are not going to go back and penalize students,” said Jara. “I want to know how they did it.”

Booker said the credit retrieval investigation will turn up nothing, and is a post-Salute attempt to paint her as a wrongdoer.

“It’s going to be the next thing, a big storm in the beginning,” said Booker. “Then they will allow me to find out what happened. Then it’ll be quiet and then they won’t tell you.”

“All of my spending money last year went to that school,” said Booker, who remains the director of Safe/Healthy Schools but has been reassigned since October as an assistant principal rotating at elementary schools.

Booker said that when the district didn’t provide a refrigerator for ACE, she brought in breakfast supplies for over a month and didn’t seek reimbursement.

The months of constant public scrutiny have taken a toll on her, said Booker. She has had people ask her if she had been arrested.

“I thought I was helping at-risk kids,” she said. “I chose not to have children. I chose to put my energy back into schools because that is what saved me. I know what it’s like to be homeless. I know what it’s like to grow up poor. I love working with kids who have those similarities.”

Booker’s principal job at ACE was handed off to a colleague in October. Jara has asked the School Board to combine three administrative jobs — ACE, adult education and dropout prevention — into one for 2012 to save money.

Booker said she is enjoying her assistant principal duties at various Keys elementaries, noting that some schools don’t even have counselors.

As for the proposed job crunch, which would eliminate her administrative job at ACE and be advertised as a new position, Booker said she understands the budget shortfall.

“I hope they do whatever they can that is best for the kids given the difficult circumstances we are in,” she said.

++++++++++++++++++++

I followed the alternative school party articles in The Citizen. Looked to me like much to do over nothing, while the school district was burning down elsewhere.

In a recent article in The Citizen, Sunny Booker’s lawyer, Robert Cintron, whom I know quite well, was reported as saying Superintendent Jara and the School District had not furnished records Cintron had requested on Sunny Booker’s behalf, records having to do with the School District’s investigation of and censure of Sunny Booker. Failure to disclose those records smells like seriously rotten fish to me.

Now Jara is on Booker about online makeup courses at a special school of perhaps 40-45 students, some of whom are learning disabled and the rest are kids seriously at risk – “headed to jail,” some would say. Some already were in jail. The very kids, if any there are, who probably need online make up courses. Some of which kids, I heard, dropped out of that school after Sunny Booker was reassigned by Jara.

I was at the School Board meeting in Key West when the Ed Options online make up program was brought up because of irregularities in how the Ed Options contract had not been property processed and brought before the School Board for approval. I became convinced at that meeting that Superintendent Jara had tried to derail the Ed Options program by keeping it away from the School Board because Jara wanted to give the business to mainland friends who had a similar product. I was astounded the School Board and its lawyer and its Internal Auditor Ken Genitle did not put Jara under severe cross-examination after he admitted he had friends on the mainland who had a similar product, after the word already was out that Jara had kept blocking the Ed Options contract from going before the School Board.

At that School Board meeting, almost like an accident, it came out that 500 Key West High School students had used the EdOptions online program to make up courses they had failed in the classroom, and that Key West High School was where that was the biggest problem in the School District. Jara should have jumped on the Principal of Key West High School the very next day.

Ah, but the Principal of Key West High School, Amber Boscoe (spelling?), was Jara’s appointee to replace now School District Chief Operating Officer Teresa Axford (spelling?). Ah, but Boscoe and Jara were buddies. Ah, but Axford and Jara were buddies. Ah, but if Jara jumped on Boscoe about 500 Key West High School Students using online courses to make up failed classes, that also would reflect on Axford. And, but all of that would reflect on Jara for appointing Boscoe to replace Axford as principal, and for promoting Axford to COO. Ah, but that would not bode well for Jara getting the three-year contract extension he later would spring without notice on the School Board at the last School Board meeting, for which indiscretion Jara was eviserated in Thursdays’ Editorial in The Citizen. Can’t help but wonder if Jara is trying to get fingers pointing at any place but at Jara, and Sunny Booker is one way to go about that.

Jara should have charged straight into Amber Boscoe’s office and demanded to know why so many Key West High School students were flunking courses and being allowed to make them up online at no expense to themselves or their families in a time when the School District is forced to make budget cuts after budget cuts. Jara should have demanded to know what was wrong in Key West High School that resulted in 500 students flunking courses.

Why did not the School Board order Jara to march into Amber Bosco’s office the next day and get to the bottom of it?

What do Jara and the School Board think the public reading in The Citizen about 500 Key West High School flunking classes and making it up online did for the .5 mil referendum’s passing? Voters want to continue that .5 mil for school operations when they see they are paying for 500 Key West High School students to flunk classes and make them up online? Voters want to vote for the referendum when it is common knowledge Key West High School students, especially, have to take remedial courses when they enter 2- or 4-year colleges? Maybe voters would rather see students flunked out and gotten off the county taxpayers’ backs, instead of passing the referendum to keep in school students who don’t pass classroom courses?

School Board John Dick asked at the Key West School Board meeting where the 500 Key West High School students flunking classes and making them up online slipped out: How far is the School District willing to go to boost graduations rates? Nobody else said a word. The other four board members should have demanded answers then and there. I sat there astonished that such an opportunity had not been seized.

I usually can be reached at keysmyhome@hotmail.com

extremism

Friday, December 30th, 2011

When Sandy Downs told me Christmas evening she had gone to Glad Tidings Tabernacle Church services in Key West that morning, I said I didn’t want to hear anything more about that church. She said Pastor Ernie had retired, another pastor was in charge now. I said I didn’t want to hear anything more about that church. She let it go.

Sandy and Pastor Ernie were buddies, and she and her family sometimes worked in the church kitchen preparing meals for homeless people. I got to know the church by being homeless and eating meals it had prepared, which was fine, except for associate pastors and church members talking down to homeless people who came to be fed.

I had direct dealings with two of associate pastors, who had lots to learn about the ways of Jesus and God; and I went to enough church services at Glad Tidings with the regular congregation to know it was not a church I figured Jesus would spend much time attending. They loved G.W. Bush and his wars, and had a high opinon of their standing with God.

The last Glad Tiding’s service I attended was at Sandy’s behest, maybe in 2008; she said she wanted me to give the church another chance. So I went, not happy about it.

 
Early in the service, after the half hour of gospel music and pentecostal swaying, hand-waving and singing to words slide-projected onto a screen, Pastor Ernie came forward and told his congregation, “You are the choicest of the choicest of the the chosen.”

I left soon after, called Sandy and said I had gone there just to here that, so I could report it back to her. It didn’t seem to go in.

Last night, I dreamt of pulling an awful, nasty, perhaps two-foot long Glad Tiding’s centipedish creature with lots of sharp claws or maybe they were teeth off of Sandy and showing it to her and telling her what it was and where it came from, and it didn’t seem to go in.

Once, a good buddy of mine was dating a woman who attended Glad Tidings and was close with Pastor Ernie. She kept throwing her religion at him, and it kept causing problems for them, so one day I dragged him into Glad Tidings for a Sunday service.

 
We sat in the back. His girlfriend came in, passed by without seeing us, sat down up front, got into the swaying and waving of hands and singing. After that was over, Pastor Ernie came forward and started speaking in his loud, projecting voice that typically caused me to want to get up and run out of his church services because the decibel level hurt me.
 
After about five more minutes, my friend bolted out of the church. We were on bicycles, and when I finally caught up with him several blocks away, he was bawling his eyes out. I told him I was sorry, but it was important for him to know what he was dealing with.

Glad Tiding’s reminded me of superstitious, closed-in, fundamentalist congregations I had gotten to know in the Birmingham area.

 
I see strong parallels in political extremists.
 
I had an email dialogue with one just yesterday. I know him somewhat, don’t know his church, but sometimes he mentions it and he frequently forwards far-right political stuff someone else forwarded to him.
 
Those forwards predictably attack President Obama, welfare recipients, people living in America who don’t speak English, and support patriotism and the troops. I get somewhat similar forwards from a Republican snowbird friend who winters a few Keys down form Little Torch. I tell them both they are racists and religious extremists in their hatred of President Obama and Democrats. Nothing to do with skin color.
 
Yesterday, the Birmingham fellow sent me a forward containing a bunch of photos of a big not exactly friendly reception President Obama received in Chicago. His photos tend not to come through, but here are the captions, followed by a chain of emails between us. His part in italics:

From: >
To:
Subject: Obama Posters in Chicago
Date: Wed, 14 Dec 2011 22:23:40 -0600
 
 
I THINK I’D FAINT IF I SAW THIS ON THE NEWS!
PHOTOS taken in Chicago on Thursday just as President Obama was arriving and got into a terrible traffic jam.
 
This was NOT seen on the nightly News on any of the Networks.

…By the way, I didn’t see the ABC, CBS,
NBC, CNN, MSNBC covering this – did you?…

Those who have visited Chicago may recognize the downtown area


Love read my lipstick : )

Redistribute my work ethic !!!


The axis of taxes : )


Love this one : )

This one is good too : )

IF you agree, Keep it going.
Let the country know the back-lash has started and we can’t afford;
…Obama or his CHANGE!…


Didn’t G.W. Bush bail out GM?

Didn’t the same Bush invent a war on false evidence the CIA did not support?

Why come Republicans don’t apply to their fallen idols the same heat they apply to the Democrats’?

Looks like religious fanaticism to me.

no, GM was 2009 Bush was out of office by then. No one invents a war. They are caused by disagreements. Sometimes with the best information available. Neither you nor I was privy to what the leaders knew at the time. Like your writings, you base your comments on your understanding of the facts. I think you do not like Obama but you don’t like Republicans either. Who would YOU elect to run the country (besides yourself, of course) LOL. I see no religion in this, only politics.
?

You are mistaken about the GM (and Chrysler) bailout:
Cheney Opposed GM Bailout – Yahoo! Autos
Former VP Dick Cheney tried to block the bailout of GM and Chrysler. Former Vice President Dick Cheney was strongly opposed to saving General Motors and Chrysler and …autos.yahoo.com/news/cheney-opposed-gm-bailout.html – Cached

Obama made worse G.W. Bush bailout of GM and Chrysler.

You have made a religion out of being a Republican, as have many Republicans. Same for many Democrats. Fanatics.

You see only what you want to see of G. W. Bush, like many Christians only see what they want to see of Jesus in the Gospels.

The CIA told President Bush there wasn’t credible evidence Iraq had WMD. Iraq had never threatened the US, but same could not be said of US toward Iraq. It was an invented war. I can’t imagine how you support G. W. Bush after what he did. It’s incomprehensible to me. Just as incomprehensible to me that Democrats support Barack Obama after he accepted the Nobel Peace Prize, while waging G.W. Bush’s wars any idiot knew were seirously dumb.

No way America ever turns around with the kind of thinking you demonstrate, which is representative of most politically-inclined Americans, regardless of political affiliation.

At this time, I see no one I would vote for President. Haven’t seen anyone in a while I felt would make a good President.

America will go the way of past world powers, if it does not make the world uninhabitable during its death throes. Hope I’m long gone by then.

?
but I am not Republican, so how is it my religion? What are you?

If you are not a Republican, then stop sending me Republican/Tea Party propaganda.

I don’t want any Democrat propaganda, either.

Nor any Ron Paul propaganda.

Nor any political propaganda.

No more wetback/hispanic-bashing from you, either.

No more support the troops stuff. The way to support the troops is to protest made-up, stupid American wars.

You belong to a right-wing cult?

Jehovah’s Witness?

John Birch Society?

Neo-Nazi?

You come across far-right-extreme, with Christian undertone.

It is a religion with you, your politics.

I belong to no political party.

nor do I belong to any party. you seem in your own world, with your own angels

Jesus, Michael and Melchezidek are not my own angels, they are your angels, too, and for all I know, they are everyone on this planet’s angels. They dragged me into their world, which makes living on this planet a bit strange much of the time. And lonely. And a lot of time waiting for them to provide engagements.

+++++++++++++++++++

Extremism is relative. I can’t imagine anything more extreme than being dragged around by Jesus, Michael and Melchizedek. No local politics engagements today, at least not any I see yet.

I usually can be reached at keysmyhome@hotmail.com

Conflicts of Interest – School District/Public, Key West/homeless

Thursday, December 29th, 2011

  

 
The first half of today’s expedition explores various conflicts of interest re the School District and the public in its relationship thereto, while the second half of today’s continues the urban terrorism query re Key West’s approach to dealing with its homeless people.
 
The School District
 
This floated down my way yesterday from Big Pine Key:

Date: Wed, 28 Dec 2011 07:00:49 -0800
From: citizenlarry007@yahoo.com
Subject: Hazel Hartman Redux
To: keysmyhome@hotmail.com

Sloan:
 
Please add _____________@gmail.com to your distribution list.
 
Having lunch tomorrow with Andy Griffiths–at his invitation. Should be interesting.
 
I hear tell that Mark Peterson has put $50,000 into his campaign account. Guess he is serious.
 
Sean Kinney’s article on Page 5A of today’s Keynoter confirms what I told you the other day about Hazel Hartman.

Larry

PS: Guess you won’t have to worry about having time to edit the Blue Paper.

Larry Murray
Citizen Advocate
 
Hi Larry:
 
Funny, I don’t see or hear Mark Peterson at AFC or School Board meetings, or promoting the referendum, or trying to cut the budget, or doing any dirty work re the school district. Maybe you should send him a bill for $50,000, if he actually put up that much. Hard to imagine anyone paying that much to try to get onto the School Board. Maybe Andy will know what the going rate is to spend for School Board races. Tell him I asked.

Ciao

 
I dunno, might be my strain of journalism takes the now demised blue paper’s strain to new extremes, or at least into new territory. Here is the Keynoter article.

By SEAN KINNEY

skinney@keynoter.com

Posted – Wednesday, December 28, 2011 10:35 AM EST

Appointed to the Monroe County School District’s Audit and Finance Committee on Dec. 13, it now appears “extremely doubtful” that Hazel Hartman will serve on the advisory panel.

That’s from district Chief Internal Auditor Ken Gentile, who said he met with Hartman following her appointment by School Board member Duncan Mathewson.
“I met with her,” Gentile said, “and she’s a little concerned about potential conflicts, not just with her position, just trying to maintain what she’s doing and trying to keep up the responsibilities of the committee.”
Hartman serves as budget director for the Big Pine Academy charter school. Board policy dictates that School District employees can’t serve on the committee, but Gentile said she isn’t an employee of the district.
However, the committee’s charter also says members should have “no direct or indirect business interests” in the schools system. Because the charter school is funded through the district, “You could say there’s at least an indirect interest,” Gentile said.
Hartman came in o the mix when Mathewson declined to reappoint Big Pine Key resident Larry Murray to another two-year term on the committee.
“She hasn’t officially said, ‘absolutely not,’ but she’s not diving in,” Gentile said. “She’s got a full-time job with what she’s doing so she’s weighing it real carefully.”
The audit committee meets monthly during the day in Marathon. Gentile estimated members devote anywhere from three to nine hours “at a minimum,” each month.
Committee Chairman Stuart Kessler acknowledged that unlike some advisory bodies, the panel he oversees puts in considerable hours scrutinizing district practices. “This has turned out to be quite an undertaking. It’s just the nature of the beast that we spend a lot of time,” he said.
Kessler said he’d be satisfied if Hartman excused herself from any future committee discussion that involved the Big Pine Academy. “That would be adequate in my opinion,” he said.
Hartman and Mathewson couldn’t be reached for comment Tuesday.

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

A few things about this story leave me a bit amazed.

Why did not Hartman decline to accept the appointment at the outset due to the conflict of interest?

Charter schools receive most of their funding from the School District. Ergo, the conflict of interest is as clear as if Hartman worked for, say, the company now supplying janitorial workers to keep the schools clean. Except, the conflict is even worse than that because Hartman works for a charter school which is part of the School District, albeit independent from School District oversight by virtue of its charter.

Why was the School Board’s Internal Auditor Ken Gentile put to raise Hartman’s conflict of interest? Why did not the School Board’s legal counsel raise the conflict of interest, since the five school board members each appoint one person to the Audit & Finance Committee?

Did School Board member Duncan Matthewson not consult with the School Board’s legal counsel before appointing Hartman to the AFC? Did Matthewson not see Hartman’s conflict of interest? As someone said to me, “Out of 70,000 people in the Keys, Matthewson chose Hartman to replace Larry Murray on the AFC?”

Why did not Stuart Kessler, who chairs the AFC and used to practice law, not speak to Hartman’s obvious conflict of interest? Why did Kessler only speak to the hard work AFC members do? Kessler has vigorously gone public with what he viewed as Sunshine Law violations committed by the School Board and by the School District during its negotiations with the teacher’s union. If anyone should have sounded the alarm over Hartman’s appointment, it was Kessler. The AFC is supposed to be independent of the School Board, Ken Gentile and the School District. The AFC is suppose to regulate itself.

On another school front, I spoke with former School Board member Stephen Pribramsky yesterday about the .5 mil referendum to continue using that tax for school district operation expenses. Steve once again said he supports the referendum but seemed concerned over hearing from the local Republican Club that older conservative Republicans are leaning toward voting against the referendum.

I had heard the Republican Club was going to lobby its members to vote for the referendum, but I suppose some Republicans are so conservative, so anti-tax, that they will vote against any tax, no matter what it’s for. Can’t say I blame them, but their voting against the .5 mil referendum would be like them voting for a Democrat instead of for a qualified Republican. This is not a partisan issue. It is a children, parents and teachers’ issue. It is a community issue.

The .5 mil referendum is on the same ballot as the Republican Florida primary on January 31. While any registered voter can vote on the referendum regardless of party affiliation or lack thereof, only Republicans can vote on the remaining items on that ballot. Meaning, Republicans have more reasons to vote on that ballot than do Democrats than Independents.

I hope Democrats and Independents will go to the polls just for the .5 mil referendum. I hope Republicans will go to the polls just for the .5 mil referendum. I hope they all will vote YES for the referendum. It is not a tax increase, but is simply a continuation of a tax already being collected. A continuation of $9 million revenue in what this year is an $80 million budget, down from over $90 million last year. Voting YES for the referendum is the right thing to do, even though the way the School Board and School District behaved in the past left much to be desired.

The way to show your pleasure or displeasure toward the School Board members is when they are up for reelection. Show your support for the children, their parents and teachers by voting YES for the .5 mil referendum. Voting against the referendum, or not voting at all, is tantamount to murder of school children, their parents and teachers, and this community. No different, in spirit, than what the Key West bubba justice system did to the Krutko family, about which I wrote a good deal recently.

 

Key West

I mentioned in yesterday’s journalism as a contact sport – Florida Keys post that about a month ago I was told in my sleep, “You will cause a lot of trouble next year,” and said it looked like I might be getting a headstart on that. I pulled part of yesterday’s post because I wasn’t sure it it wasn’t a bit overboard, and because I have gotten hammered plenty of times in the past by the angels for going a bit overboard in posts. However, during my morning passout time yesterday, dreams left me feeling the angels thought I got to loafing a bit yesterday and should roll a bowling ball a bit harder, and louder, so here is what I pulled from yesterday’s post because I was terrified of overstepping and incurring THE WRATH OF GOD.

++++++++++++++++++++++++

Just after was Craig Cates was elected Mayor of Key West in 2009, he and his campaign manager both thanked me for Craig winning without a runoff, as I had told voters to vote for Craig if they did not vote for me. Craig then asked me if I would be on his homeless advisory committee? I said sure, just let me know when and where to show up. I never heard from Craig about that again.

When maybe a year later, I read in The Citizen that Craig was doing a mayor’s homeless tour, I called him on his cell phone and said I would like to tag along since it was something I knew about and he had asked me to be on his homeless advisory committee. He tried to talk me out of it, said he didn’t want trouble, which I was known to cause. I said I would be there.

I went on the mayor’s homeless tour, and it was I who introduced Craig to homeless people, while the others along stood back, including Police Chief Donie Lee and one of his Captains who was assigned to homeless outreach for the KWPD. Looked to me, if I had not been there, they would not have tried to meet any homeless people during that tour.

I am not the only person Craig shut out of his homeless advisory committee after inviting participation.

Craig asked Father Stephen Braddock, who runs Florida Keys Outreach Coalition, to be on the mayor’s homeless advisory committee. Steve accepted the invitation, then he never heard from Craig again. Craig told me that Steve was hard to get along with and did not want to participate. On learning of that from me, Steve rebutted with copies of emails from him to Craig asking to participate, emails that went unanswered by Craig.

It would be naive to think that rebuff by Craig did not influence Steve wanting FKOC to give KOTS back to the City of Key West to run. Steve never wanted FKOC to take on KOTS to begin with. In fact, FKOC delined to have anything to do with the building and opening of KOTS. Steve and I both told city officials KOTS would be a nightmare if the city opened it. We told them the truth, and only after the city begged Steve to come in and bail out the City did FKOC finally assume management of KOTS for the City at about 1/3 the fee commanded in the open market.

When I wrote about all of that some months ago, I said not long after Craig was sworn in, his daughter ran over a homeless man on his bicycle on North Roosevelt Blvd and the man later died from it. It appeared to be the man’s fault, but the trauma to Craig’s daughter was devastating, thus to her mother and father. I wrote that tragedy was coloring Craig’s judgment re the homeless.

Only as I wrote that did I recall that Craig’s wife Cheryl is a Realtor. No way do Realtors want any homeless people in Key West. Realtors, the Chamber of Commerce and Craig want homeless people converted back to mainstream living, or out of the Key West area altogether. Their One Human Family does not include homeless people.

So for various reasons, I suppose, on the homeless issue Craig is not in touch with reality, and since he asked me to be on his homeless advisory committee, I keep giving him minority reports which he keeps continuing to ignore because my reports do not agree with his illusion.

As I wrote twice before now, let KOTS be closed by Attorney Bart Smith’s lawsuit on behalf of the condo development near KOTS. Let Craig then try to move KOTS into another Key West neighborhood. Let then Craig find out for himself what Key West people are capable of, since he does not care to hear anything I tell him about homelessness in Key West.

If Craig ever goes through that fire baptism, he will think homeless people are wonderful compared to the Key West people he enraged by trying to relocate KOTS in their neighborhood.

If you still think I am inciting terrorism, you are insane. It is Craig Cates who will incite terrorism, if he tries to move KOTS to another Key West neighborhood. If Craig doesn’t believe me, he should speak with Jimmy Weekley, Julio Avael and John Jones, who got what for from that neighborhood near the soup kitchen on Flagler Avenue, for trying to put something like KOTS next to the west side of the airport.

But even that conversation might not get Craig’s attention. He has become a homeless religious fanatic. It may be that nothing will return him to sanity re homeless people. I could say the same thing about most of Key West re homeless people.

I told the the female shaman and her fellow I had over for Christmas dinner, for all I know, Jesus, Michael and Melchizedek will have me be homeless in Key West again. For all I know, I have not finished what they sent me homeless to Key West in late 2000 to do.

I can see those three telling me if I’m homeless again, for me to sue the City of Key West in Federal Court under the Pottinger case. I know how to do it, maybe it would make my life more interesting, although I certainly didn’t find living on the street before particularly interesting.

First, I get myself harassed by city police for sleeping outside at night in Key West. Then, I get myself thrown in jail for not getting up and moving on. After being released, or bailed out, might make an interesting front page piece in The Citizen, I file the lawsuit, now having legal standing to do so. Perhaps FKOC, or someone, lets me have a bed and access to a shower inside in exchange for my prosecuting the city under the Pottinger case. I have a laptop. All I need is access to a printer.

Accompanying the lawsuit is a request for injunctive relief against the city for not letting homeless people sleep outside, or in their vehicles, when there is no room in KOTS for them to sleep there.

Also is a request for CRIMINAL SANCTIONS (imprisonment) for Mayor Cates, the city commissioners, the city manager, the city attorney and the chief of police for subjecting me and all members of the class I represent to cruel and unusual punishment in violation of the Bill of Rights of the US Constitution and in violation of the US Civil Rights Acts which provide for CRIMINAL PROSECUTION, as opposed to mere civil prosectution which was the Pottinger case.

A criminal prosecution similar to what I told Robert Krutko his lawyer should initiate against the City of Key West and against Key West attorney Michael Halpern and his plaintiffs, Judge David Audlin and State Attorney Dennis Ward and Assistant Attorney Mark Wilson, for what they did to Krutko and his family, which broke them and caused them to become homeless, about which crimes I wrote a good bit lately. I told Krutko his lawyer should take his and his family’s case to the F.B.I. and the US Department of Justice.

The Krutkos aside, the prosecution I file against Key West and its officials takes the definition of urban terrorism to an entirely new level. However, I do not expect to live very long after filing it, and I do not expect to hear from Todd German, nor from any of his politically-correct Key West friends, objection or concern that I incited local acts terrorism against myself by filing that prosecution. Au contraire, I expect to hear them say I got what I asked for.

The female shaman I had with her fellow over for Christmas and a fish dinner went bonkers when I said for all I know Jesus, Michael and Melchizedek might have me be homeless again. She hammered me over and over about having free will, the power to do what I wanted. She said I did not have to listen to Jesus, Michael and Melchizdek. I wondered where she got her shaman training?

I did not wonder why she was bonkers. It was obvious. She and her fellow were worried sick about running out of money and having to go homeless. Instead of facing up to that, instead of considering they were being tested, she projected all of her fear of going homeless again (she had tried it on once before in Montreal), and her hatred of God for it perhaps happening again, onto me and God.

She knew nothing about projection, which is the first thing Jesus, Michael and Melchizedek taught me, in spades. For years, they stood me in front of a mirror. It was horrible. For even more years, they had me do things I did not want to do. I have only known one person, who was a female shaman, who was my sixth wife, who really experienced what it is like to be fully leaned on my Jesus, Michael and Melchizedek unceasing, and by others they sometimes send in.

The Kingdom of God truly is not of this world. Simply stated, it is: “Not my but Thy will be done, O Lord.” That was why the female shaman met me, to hear that said over and over. That, and for me to be told to tell her to do a shaman journey to where Jesus, Michael and Melchizdek waited to speak to her about me, and about her. Maybe she will make that journey, maybe not. She said she would make it and would let me know what happened. If I hear from her about that, I imagine I will report what she said.

I usually can be reached at keysmyhome@hotmail.com

journalism as a contact sport – Florida Keys

Wednesday, December 28th, 2011

 

 

The Citizen reports today that Key West the Newspaper went out of business again, this time for good, and its Pubisher Dennis Reeves Cooper plans to move to a small town in the Brazilian rainforest. The blue newspaper, which promoted journalism “as a contact sport”, is no longer. R.I.P.
 
On similar theme, recent emails with Deer Ed of bigpinekey.com’s Coconut Telegraph:

Morning after ho, ho, ho, Ed, wish I felt ho, ho, ho, but that’s beside the point of this inquiry.

Can’t tell whether you seriously are looking at closing the CT, or you just wanted to stir the pot because you wuz getting bored.

Did any of the CT lovers who begged you to keep the CT going ever offer to pay you anything for that?

Maybe a rhetorical question, since I didn’t see anything along that line pubished.

Sloan

It’s true, Sloan, I’m burnt out after ten years. I wear the CT like an anchor around my soul. Someone did send me $5, but it’s not the money, it’s the 365 X 10 year work week that’s got me down.~Ed

 
Gosh, Ed, sounds like how I feel …

I read today on the CT, you said you liked a reader’s comment that you do no-edit Sat and Sun, so you can have weekends off, but I know no-edit takes some work, too, only less work than full-edit days …

Why not try taking Sat and Sun off altogether, just publish M-F, and tell CT readers no submissions made Fri or Sat will be considered for weekly CT, so you won’t have them trickling while you are resting or whatever …

If you quit altogther, though, I will understand why and probably won’t bitch too much … but what about all of the CT addicts you have created? And what about the Sloan haters?

So many things to consider, but I would start with you, if allowed that freedom …

 
++++++++++++++++++
 
During Christmas dinner at Walden with a female shaman and her fellow, she showed me online slides of their lovely hacienda in Brazil and invited me to R & R there anytime I wished. Otherwise, the get together was non-stop disagreement between her and me. How does someone who is not living in my skin presume to know what I deal with 24-7, 365? How does someone not being run by Jesus, Michael and Melchizedek unceasing presume to tell me I can shuck them anytime I want to shuck them? Finally, it came to me out of the blue to say to her, “You are a shaman, do a shaman journey and go to where they are and hear what they have to say. They will speak to you about me, and about things about you that you are struggling with.” A perfect solution, yet she would not lay off. Finally, I told them to leave. Well, she had said she was yearning to eat fish, and I had understood later she meant Jesus. So I served them fresh mutton snapper and Jesus. The snapper was terrific, she loved it, but she didn’t seem to care much for Jesus. A typical Christmas arranged by the angels. I think next Christmas, if I’m still around, I will go it alone.

I was told about a month ago in my sleep, “You will cause lots of trouble next year.” Looks like I could be getting a head start. I figured after taking three naps before lunch yesterday, that some major shit was coming in.

The first crapola the wind blew in was on Ron Paul from Sancho Panza.


THEY are very afraid of this MAN… what do your Angels say about him?
the smartest and most humane person left on earth
 

 
Vote Ron Paul 2012, save America, secure your job, privacy, kids’ future.
00:04:26
Added on 12/27/11
80 views
 
 

Watched the video, will ask your angels, same as my angels, to speak to me about RON Paul, if they have anything to add.

Wish you had seen the recent news interview on one of the early evening CNN news programs where Paul was asked about the newsletter his organization put out: after 911 the newsletter accused Israel of being behind it. Paul said he had not read that particular newsletter, did not read them all the time.

How could he not have known that was in that particular newsletter? His entire demeanor was evasive, pure political. He had me moving his way until then. No longer, although he does seem to be saner than the other Repubilcan candidates.

Democrats not sane, either.

 
00:10:47
Added on 10/25/11
35,951 views
 
 
I have known about Ron Paul since his bid for the Republican Nomination back in 2007-2008! I have yet to see him being anything but unequivocal on any issue! Whether people like him or not, he pretty much says what he thinks… just like you!

Watch this whole video until the end!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rH1FaLdABFM&feature=related

There are many youtube videos about Ron Paul’s position on Foreign Aid and our Support for Israel and any other “foreign entanglement”! Ron Paul says, cut them all out, we cannot be the police of the World and we can’t make people like us by bombing them to death… he’s a lonely voice clamoring in the desert, another Don Q!

 
 
You missed the point entirely, Sancho. When cornered with his own flub, Ron Paul did what all politicians do when cornered with their flubs.

I preached cutting Israel completely off since just after 911. I opposed every US war after I woke up about Vietnam. I opposed John Kerry and both Bushes. I did not get my ideas from Ron Paul, of whom I had not heard, as I recall, before you told me about him.

 
This video was created by TheChannelOfLiberty and features various video clips of Ron Paul from 1983 and later. In those clips, Paul sounds just like he does today, but instead of laughing at him,…
00:10:00
Added on 2/20/10
57,458 views
 
 
this utube is different from what you sent earlier to me, Sancho?
 
 
JUST FORGET ABOUT IT!!!
 
 
You invited me and the angels into this discussion, Sancho.

Now you tell me to forget all abou it, with exclamations, after I don’t swoon over Paul.

Spock would say you are behaving illogically.

Just saw another TV news discussion re those Ron Paul newsletters, apparently he still has not come clean.

One fellow made an interesting comment, along the lines: to say Paul didn’t know what was in, or he didn’t read what was in, the newsletters was stretching it; as was to say Paul was a racist over what was written stretching it; but it showed Paul associated with fringe-thinkers he could not control.

I wish Paul had just said, yeah, we put that out, we believed then, that Israel was behind 911; wish we had not put it out. That he did not do that leaves me thinking, hmmm, he still believes Israel was behind 911. Back then, I would not have ruled that possiblilty out before Osama bin Laden boasted on videos that went onto the Internet that he and his gang had done it.

I don’t get the sense that Paul is a racist. Rather, it seems he trust no foreign countries, and I can’t say I blame him for that. As I said before, I was moving his way until I saw the way he petered out over the newsletters.

In a way, this reminds me of Barry Goldwater getting called during his campaign on his relationship with the John Birch Society, and Goldwater would not back down on supporting extremism in support of democracy.

In a way, it also reminds me of my experience with Barack Obama before he secured the Democratic nomination. After a while, I knew something was seriously wrong with him and sounded the clarion.

I took three naps today, so far. Nothing from the angels on Ron Paul, so far. They will let me know, if I am not looking at him clearly.

 

+++++++++++++++++++++

The angels stayed mum, meaning they have nothing to add to what I wrote to Sancho who asked for their input. Be careful what you ask for, I suppose.
 
In similar vein was Todd German telling me yesterday on the telephone that he had a little bone to pick with me about the highlighted sentence from this part of the recent What would Jesus do – Key West’s homeless? post:

Cates said he isn’t concerned that the civil suit will shutter KOTS.
THE CITY WASN’T CONCERNED IT WOULD LOSE THE DUCK TOURS CASE, EITHER.
“It’s too important,” he said. “When we didn’t have KOTS, the homeless were camping all over town, out on the boulevard. Without having a shelter, you can’t make them leave that area. We have to have it, wherever it ends up being.”
MAYOR CATES PERCEIVED IMPORTANCE OF KOTS HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH DECIDING THAT LAWSUIT. THE CITY BUILT KOTS WITHOUT GAINING THE NECESSARY CITY, COUNTY, STATE AND FEDERAL APPROVALS. THE CITY IS ABOVE THE LAW?
IF MAYOR CATES EVER TELLS A KEY WEST NEIGHBORHOOD KOTS WILL BE RELOCATED IN THEIR BACK YARD, HE WILL FIND OUT PRONTO HE DID NOT GET A MANDATE IN THE LAST CITY ELECTIONS TO DO THAT. HE WILL FIND OUT PRONTO KEY WEST’S ONE HUMAN FAMILY CREED DOES NOT APPLY TO THE HOMELESS. HE MIGHT FIND OUT KEY WEST CITIZENS ARE NOT ABOVE TERRORIST RETALIATION AGAINST THEIR MAYOR AND HIS FAMILY, AND I DO NOT MEAN PAINTING UNPLEASANT STUFF ON OLD TOWN WALLS.

Todd said a couple of people had told him they felt I had incited people to commit acts of terrorism against Mayor Cates and his family. Meaning, Todd felt that way, too. I was flabbergasted, said as much.

Under query, Todd said he knew nothing about the neighborhood meeting in the church on Flagler Avenue, near the soup kitchen, when Jimmy Weekey was mayor. When Weekley, City Manager Julio Avael and Assistant City Manager John Jones presented to that neighborhood putting a homeless residential community near the west side of the airport, the way into and out of which was a single road through that neighborhood connecting to Flagler Avenue. A firestorm erupted at that meeting, Weekely switched positions, said something like not in his city!!! Weekley, Avael and Jones tucked tail and ran. All as reported to me by Avael and Jones, and The Citizen. As I recollect, that was in early June 2003.

That red hot incident was why Key West later approached the county and sheriff about putting KOTS next to the sheriff headquarters and jail.

I was astounded someone as versed and active in Key West politics as Todd did not know of that neighborhood meeting. I would be astounded to learn Mayor Craig Cates does not know of it. I would be astounded Craig did not know exactly what I meant when I wrote what I did. He is a many generations Conch. He knows what Key West locals are capable of doing when they become enraged.

I told Todd, if I wrote about it, to try to clarify what I had written, it would only make it worse. Todd said he was sorry if he had made it worse.

A little while after Todd and I had said goodbye, another thought occurred to me.

I got to know Craig Cates pretty well during the 2009 mayor’s race. I eventually started telling people that Craig was a good man and to vote for him, if they didn’t want to vote for me. I said don’t vote for the other two mayor candidates: incumbent Mayor Morgan McPherson and Mike Mongo. I said that at candidate forums and in posts to my websites.

Then, after Craig was sworn in, I started to see he tended to see things only his way, even though his mantra during his campaign was he just wanted everyone to get along. Meaning, I can see Craig might have no clue what his fellow Key Westers are capable of doing if they get mad enough. I can see, if KOTS is closed and Craig tries to move it into a Key West neighborhood, he could come to think homeless people are wonderful compared to the people living in that neighborhood.

I wonder if my readership will go up now that the contact journalism sport lovers no longer have Key West the Newspaper to read? I wonder if my readership will increase if Deer Ed shuts down the CT? I wonder if I should head for Brazil? Like Jesus, Michael and Melchizdek would let me, even if I wanted to go there, which I don’t. Seems they have plenty of jungle around here they want me enjoy. Such a sense of humor – theirs.

I usually can be reached at keysmyhome@hotmail.com
 
 

Florida Keys foreign exchange – school district & KOTS

Tuesday, December 27th, 2011


cartoon compliments my oldest Bashinsky first cousin Leo

The first half of today’s foreign exchange explores more school district finance, the second half more KOTS.

Part I

Date: Mon, 26 Dec 2011 11:28:35 -0800
From: citizenlarry007@yahoo.com
Subject: The Cat Is Out Of The Bag
To:
keysmyhome@hotmail.com

Sloan:

Some of your readers may not have heard Bill Becker’s interview of School Superintendent Jesus Jara last Friday on “Morning Magazine”. The interview proved to be very enlightening.

While discussing District finances, Supt. Jara commented that the budget deficit for next year, assuming failure of the .5 mil referendum, could reach $14 million! Becker immediately picked up on that number, noting that previous estimates were in the $12 million range and he asked for an explanation. Supt. Jara responded that the additional $2 million would be necessary to meet the state mandated Fund Balance of 3%.

As you know, it is not easy to follow the bouncing ball of District finances. Everyone should take a look at the “FY 2012/2013-Preliminary Analysis” prepared by Michael Kinneer, CFO, on December 1, 2011. That report was presented at the most recent meetings of both the Audit and Finance Committee and the School Board.

As of 12/1/11, Kinneer is projecting a deficit for next year, 2012-2013, of $2,809,793 at a minimum. For the District to replenish its Fund Balance to the state mandated 3%, that projected deficit would rise to $5,055,097. And, these are optimistic projections as they assume passage of the .5 mil referendum.

Further complicating matters is the suggestion by many, including Board member Robin Smith-Martin that the Fund Balance be raised to somewhere in the neighborhood of 5%. The argument is that beginning the year with a barely acceptable 3% Fund Balance is much too risky as budget amendments throughout the year always draw down the Fund Balance, as is currently the case.

While being exact is always difficult when it comes to District finances, a 1% Fund Balance number equals somewhere in the neighborhood of $750,000 to $1,000,000. If the Fund Balance is raised to 5%, for example, that would increase the projected deficit on the low side to $6,555,097 and to $7,055,097 on the high side!! Again, those deficit numbers presume passage of the .5 mil referendum.

CFO Kinneer is already projecting an end of year Fund Balance of 2.43% for the current 2011-12 fiscal year which will necessitate reporting that deficiency to the state. If history is any indicator, budget amendments for the remainder of the year are likely to cause Mr. Kinneer’s projection to fall even further. His projections for the current fiscal year assume no additional budget amendments, something that is as likely as snow in the Keys. I fully expect the Fund Balance to drop below the 2% threshold sometime this year and that will activate state involvement in the financial administration of the School District.

Supt. Jara is trying to cover the current deficit by reducing expenditures. Those recommendations, I believe, are suspect at best and I will have more to say on that subject later.

Other than that, how was your Christmas?

Larry

Larry Murray

Citizen Advocate

 

I did not hear the radio interview either. The school budget is seriously complicated.

I attended two Audit & Finance (AFC) meetings where the school district’s Chief Financial Officer Michael Kinneer painted a budget shortfall next fiscal school year of $13-15 million, if the .5 referendum failed to pass, and a $4-6 million shortfall if the referendum passed. During the first of those meetings, after Kinneer was pressed by others there to basically agree that there would be a flat flat income next year, I asked Kinneer if he believed income would remain flat? He said no, he felt it would fall due to falling land values, thus falling ad valorem tax revenues.

I was told by Larry Murray, and I had heard at school board meetings and at AFC meetings, the shool district is required by the state to maintain a 3 percent of revenues reserve, which is called the “fund balance.” If the fund balance falls below 3 percent, Larry said the school district has to notify the state, and then discussion is suppose to happen about how to get the fund balance back up to 3 percent. Larry said if the fund balance falls below 2 percent, the school district has to notify the state, and then the state comes down to the Keys and gets directly involved in running the school district and getting the fund balance back up to 3 percent.

I said the fund balance should never be allowed to fall below 3 percent, and when a required expenditure comes up that will deplete the fund balance below 3 percent, corresponding spending cuts should be made elsewhere to keep the fund balance from falling below 3 percent. Larry agreed. He agreed when I said the school should budget for the worst case scenario every year. And he agreed when I said the more confused the public is about school district finances, the more likely the public will vote against the .5 mil referendum, which represents $9 in school district income.

The school district budget this fiscal school year is around $80 million. So, if the referendum fails, the school district’s income this fiscal school year will be around $71 million.

For next year, decrease that by the $4-6 million Michael Kinneer said at the AFC meetings will have to come off regardless of how the .5 mil referendum goes, and you end up with a $65-67 million budget for next year, if the referendum fails.

You tell me, how will the school district be able to spend keep the fund balance above 2 percent and stop the state from coming in and taking over the school district, if the .5 mil referendum fails to pass?

Tell me how the school district will be able to spend a penny on school sports, band, elective courses, make up courses, online courses, new charter school enrollments, with that much lower a budget?

Tell me how will the school district be able to keep all schools open?

How will the school district be able to avoid bussing grammar school kids, with older kids, to high schools?

Tell me how the school district will keep the good teachers after cutting their pay in the highest cost of living county in the state?

Tell me why the school district has not already made $6 million worst case scenario in cost cuts Michael Kinner predicts for next fiscal school year, even if the .5 referendum passes?

Tell me why the school district keeps putting off to next year what needs to be dealt with this year?

If the school district and school board do not think the public are wondering the same thing, the school district is mistaken.

The teachers’ union learned the school district has to operate within its means when the state recently ruled the school district’s dire financial situation was good reason for it to renegotiate a collective bargaining agreement the school district and the school board never should have agreed to in the first place.

Larry Murray told me that he told superintendent Joe Burke and board chairman John Dick that he did not see enough money to fund the collective bargaining agreement.

I wonder how much it cost the school district to pay an outside labor lawyer to fix what would have been avoided if the school district and the school board had listened to Larry Murray?

I usually can be reached at keysmyhome@hotmail.com.

Part II

A Key Largo reply to yesterday’s What would Jesus do –Key West’s homeless? post:

Hi Sloan,

I am still of the opinion that this new KOTS “changes” initiative is really all about the potential of getting grant money. The people now running it come from that grant mentality, idealistic, “well-meaning”.

Of all the comments in the Citizen article, AB Molloy’s were the most realistic, probably because she is on the front lines of crazy addicted every day at the GCC.

As for KW officials not consulting you or others who have personal experience, it’s about who impresses them. You don’t impress them. That guy who did the presentation about his (alleged) success some place – he impressed them. They’ve got it backwards and it’s their loss. Also the homeless’ and community’s loss. Bunch of amateurs fiddling with peoples’ lives. Which is not to say the homeless have no responsibility for their actions. They still have to conduct themselves within the boundaries, mostly for their own immediate well being.

The KOTS facility is not currently physically arranged for areas to offer any social services, job hunting or counseling. And that’s no loss, because those services are already available elsewhere in KW, and the KOTS residents probably know that. To use those services or not use those services is – so far – the residents’ choice to make.

Forcing or not forcing people to use “helping” “services” (both words are dubious) is a very old dilemma, the subject of volumes, source of many college professors’ incomes.

Very bothersome to me are people who can not just accept, who must always imprint their theories ideologies, make people bend to whatever social norm is currently in vogue. Those people are in just as much denial as the people they think they are trying to help, or more. Sometimes, providing safe sleep and food is the most that can be done. Although that does not appease the judgement passers, or law enforcers.

Switching thoughts –

How are the people the neighborhood next to KOTS any different than the people in neighborhoods where a future shelter might be placed? They’re not. What you say about those KW’ers – that they don’t want it, is exactly what the current neighbors are saying. The difference is that the current neighbors had no say in the decision, but future neighbors will have the opportunity to protest. Preserving home values is sacrosanct, and the city (county?) violated that covenant.

Hi, Sue

Received this email comment today from distant in-law who used to vacation a good bit in Key West:

SLOAN – I read your post regarding the KOTS agenda. It is really difficult for me to believe that the ” enabler mafia” does not have more common sense. I sense that the current direction that has been dictated for KOTS will come to no good end.

On another note….. I hope you have a productive and peaceful new year. “fair winds”

Ron

Been so long since I’ve seen “fair winds,” I wonder if such even exist. Seems ill winds are blowing strong around KOTS.

Perhaps, as you say, it is about them hoping to get grant money. However, if they turn KOTS into a rehab shelter, or a pay to stay shelter, or both, they will run off a lot of their “regulars” and the city will be in a serious bind trying to stop them from living as they did before KOTS gave the city an excuse to arrest them for sleeping outside. The city either doesn’t see the downside, or feels impervious.

Looks to me, the best case scenario for the city is to leave KOTS alone and hope the condominium association plaintiffs do not win the lawsuit and shut KOTS down. Why be experimenting with KOTS when you don’t even know if it will remain in existence? I imagine any grant applications will have to require disclosure of the lawsuit, so the solicited grant providers will know KOTs could cease to exist. I imagine not disclosing the lawsuit in grant applications might be some sort of crime.

A.B. Maloy is a lawyer. Although still pretty new heading up the Guidance-Care Clinic, she could be saying to the press and Mayor Cates, there is no way KOTS can be operated as a rehab shelter unless KOTS users are required to pass urine tests. Of course, everyone involved in KOTS knows such screening will reduce KOTS users by about 95 percent, and guess where they would sleep? Right, where they slept before they used KOTS. Catch-22, if you kick them out of KOTS, you have to let them sleep somewhere, according to the Pottinger case anyway. Same US District Court which decided Pottinger, re Miami’s homeless, has jurisdiction over Key West.

It looks to me like Mayor Cates, and others, have turned rehabbing homeless people into a religious crusade, the undercurrent of which is to run out of the Key West area all homeless to do not buy into Mayor Cates and the others’ religion for homeless people. Doesn’t look to me they have factored in the Pottinger case.

Yes, homeless people are responsible for their side of this, and some of them act responsibility and some of them do not. However, acting responsibly doesn’t mean the same thing to most homeless people, that it means to most mainstream people. That’s how it is with homeless people, and it’s not going to change because Mayor Cates and others want it to change.

As for your last question, KOTS is at the end of a paved road where the sheriff headquarters and jail are. A separate road to the east goes into the nearest neighborhood, which is the condominium development that sued to have KOTS closed because the proper goverment building permits were not obtained. As far as I know, the homeless don’t even use that road, and my sense is there is more to that lawsuit than direct concern about homeless people in the area.

Also, KOTS is on county property in the Key West city limits, and that condo development is on city land. So I don’t think the condo development had much leverage re KOTS going in by the sheriff headquarters and jail, easily the safest place to put it. There was a county commission meeting on it back when Dixie Spehar was County Mayor. I asked the county commissioners at that meeting why they were undertaking to bail Key West out of its problem which was not the county’s problem? So KOTS was publicly vetted.

Am interested to see how the judge who got the condo association’s lawsuit will field it. Will the case go by the rule of law, or by the bubba justice method? Key West operated by the bubba justice method until the Duck Tours case spoiled that party. Now we have the Krutko’s lawsuit againt the bubba justice method, and now the condominium association’s lawsuit. Maybe the rule of law will become dominant in Key West.

Sloan

I usually can be reached at keysmyhome@hotmail.com.

What would Jesus do – Key West’s homeless?

Monday, December 26th, 2011

This was in The Citizen yesterday, my thoughts in CAPS:

Homelessness advisers conjure ideas to end enabling

BY GWEN FILOSA Citizen Staff
gfilosa@keysnews.com
 
Even the idea of charging the men and women who sleep at the city’s homeless shelter per night — maybe they could fork over 50 cents or a couple of dollars, all to pay for new services — doesn’t exist without fears of blowback.Could “client fees” ramp up panhandling downtown or even drive Key West’s homeless away from the Stock Island free shelter?“I want to make sure they are not back in the mangroves or on the streets,” A.B. Maloy, executive director of the Guidance/Care Center, said during a recent meeting of nonprofit leaders entrusted with revamping the shelter. “Ideally, we want people seeking shelter to get resources. We all need a place to crash as well.”

The nightly fee is just one example of how making any changes to the shelter is no easy job. The city reserves $400,000 a year to run the place on College Road, but not much is available to bring in new services.

Those who work on the frontlines of the island’s impoverished and afflicted population know that what may sound good on paper doesn’t always prove effective.

I THINK IT’S TIME FOR THESE SELF-PROCLAIMED HOMELESS EXPERTS TO LEARN THROUGH EXPERIENCE HOW EXPERT THEY ARE. QUIT TALKING. CHARGE KOTS USERS A FEE. SEE WHAT HAPPENS.

Significant changes will come to Key West’s shelter in the new year, according to the mayor and the team of nonprofit leaders charged with transforming the threadbare, fenced-in bunkhouse into a “therapeutic community” that offers job training and counseling.

Since its inception in 2004, the makeshift facility has always been an “emergency shelter.” In 2012, a collective of city leaders and nonprofit heads envision a transitional center that offers a way out for at least a portion of the regulars there.

THE EMERGENCY WAS KEY WEST’S, NOT THE HOMELESS’. KEY WEST WAS FRANTIC TO STOP THE HOMELESS FROM SLEEPING OUTSIDE AT NIGHT AND THE ONLY WAY THE CITY LEGALLY COULD DO IT WAS TO PROVIDE THE HOMELESS WITH A SHELTER. THAT WAS WHY KOTS WAS BUILT AND OPENED. THERE WAS NO OTHER REASON. IF YOU DON’T BELIEVE ME, ASK FORMER CITY MANAGER JULIO AVAEL, FORMER ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER JOHN JONES, FLORIDA KEYS OUTREACH COALITION CEO FATHER STEPHEN BRADDOCK AND KEY WEST ATTORNEY SAMUEL KAUFMAN WHO REPRESENTED THE HOMELESS AGAINST THE CITY BACK THEN.

IF THE CITY CLOSES THE SHELTER TO THE “REGULARS” WHO DO NOT CHANGE TO SUIT THE NEW KOTS REGIME, THE CITY WILL HAVE TO LET THE “REGULARS” WHO LEAVE SLEEP OUTSIDE AT NIGHT – THAT IS THE LAW. IN FACT, THE LAW IS (THE POTTINGER CASE), IF THERE IS NO ROOM FOR THEM AT KOTS, HOMELESS CAN SLEEP OUTSIDE AT NIGHT.

But that vision is the only definite decision that has been made for the Keys Overnight Temporary Shelter, two months after the Southernmost Homeless Assistance League stepped up to manage it for the city after a civil lawsuit prompted the former nonprofit, Florida Keys Outreach Coalition, to wash its hands of the place.

FKOC WASHED ITS HANDS OF A PLACE IT YEARS BEFORE HAD TOLD THE CITY WAS A BAD IDEA AND THE CITY BUILT KOTS ANYWAY AND IT TURNED INTO A SALOON, STREET DRUG PARLOR, BROTHEL AND DISEASE CENTER JUST LIKE FKOC TOLD THE CITY WOULD HAPPEN. SO THE CITY BEGGED FKOC TO TAKE OVER KOTS, WHICH FKOC RELUCTANTLY DID FOR ABOUT ONE-THIRD OF WHAT IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN PAID. FKOC STRAIGHTENED OUT KOTS AND RAN IT FOR SEVERAL YEARS UNTIL FKOC WAS SUED. LAWSUITS HURT NON-PROFITS GRANT FUNDING AND THAT’S WHY FKOC “WASHED IT’S HANDS” OF KOTS. IF THE PLAINTIFFS WIN THAT LAWSUIT, THERE WILL BE NO KOTS NEXT TO THE JAIL AND THE SELF-APPOINTED HOMELESS EXPERTS WILL FIND OUT WHAT THE CITY FOUND OUT BEFORE KOTS WAS BUILT: NO NEIGHBORHOOD IN KEY WEST WHERE THERE IS ROOM FOR A KOTS WILL STAND FOR IT BEING LOCATED IN THEIR BACKYARD.

Since SHAL took over the management contract, life at the shelter has remained the same: People line up for the 6:30 p.m. opening of the gates for a bunk, a shower and a movie shown on a modest television. Lights out at 11 p.m. Roll out is at 7 a.m.

“Incremental changes” will come in January, SHAL Executive Director Wendy Coles said during Tuesday’s meeting of the KOTS advisory council that includes leaders from three additional nonprofits that are not legally involved with Keys Overnight Temporary Shelter.

Instead, Star of the Sea Outreach Mission, Samuel’s House, and the Guidance/Care Center offered to help craft a new day for the city’s response to providing a homeless shelter. At the recent meeting in Key West, the council hashed out ideas for putting the KOTS crowd on the road to recovery.

“The taxpayers of this city don’t want to continue enabling,” said Tom Callahan, director of Star of the Sea, a food bank on Stock Island, who described KOTS’ past pitch as, “Come in and stay at our temporary shelter for the rest of your life.”

STAR OF THE SEA IS THE ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH IN KEY WEST. DID TOM FORGET IT IS MORE BLESSED TO GIVE THAN TO RECEIVE? DID TOM FORGET JESUS TOLD HIS DISCIPLES IN THE GOSPELS THAT THE POOR WOULD ALWAYS BE WITH THEM? DID TOM FORGET JESUS AND HIS DISCIPLES WERE HOMELESS?

For starters, shelter director Nancy Banks has started talking to regulars who sleep at KOTS about a new initiative that would place a dozen homeless in volunteer jobs that help keep the shelter clean. In exchange for their manual labor, the volunteers would get three meals and perhaps an assigned bunk and laundry privileges.

“Five days a week they are actually doing something,” said Maloy. “That is what basic outreach is. The evidence indicates that it’s a mixed bag. Some people will benefit from it and some won’t.”

Banks reminded the group that there are grave reasons why some of the KOTS guests are chronically homeless — disabilities that range from physical ailments to mental illness.

OTHER KOTS GUESTS ARE CHRONICALLY ADDICTED TO MIND-ALTERING DRUGS, AND OTHERS SIMPLY NO LONGER CARE TO LIVE THE MAINSTREAM WAY. IF THE CITY REALLY WANTS TO TURN KOTS INTO A REHAB SHELTER, THE FIRST STEP TO REHAB IS TO DRY OUT. LIKE FLORIDA KEYS OUTREACH COALITION FOR HOMELESS MEN AND SAMUEL’S HOUSE FOR HOMELESS WOMEN DO, A NEW KOTS REHAB SHELTER SHOULD ONLY ALLOW IN HOMELESS WHO HAVE CLEAN URINE. THEN SEE HOW MANY “REGULARS” PASS THAT TEST, MAYBE FIVE PERCENT. THE REST WILL SLEEP OUTSIDE, IN THEIR VEHICLES, ETC.

“This is a privilege, not a right,” said Callahan. “They need to work to keep it.”

KOTS IS NO PRIVILEGE. THE CITY PROVIDES KOTS BECAUSE THE CITY DOESN’T WANT HOMELESS PEOPLE SLEEPING OUTSIDE AT NIGHT. TOM CALLAHAN NOT ONLY DOES NOT SEEM KNOW WHAT JESUS WAS ABOUT, HE ALSO DOES NOT SEEM KNOW THE HISTORY OF KOTS, OR THE LAW.

But even Callahan proposed one question: Should the volunteer crew be made up of those who wish to better themselves, or be reserved for people who likely will remain in the ranks of the homeless until they die?

IF ANY KOTS USERS WISH TO HELP KEEP KOTS CLEAN, TERRIFIC, BUT TO COUNT ON KOTS USERS KEEPING A FACILITY THAT SIZE CLEAN AND DISEASE FREE IS IMPROBABLE.

No one had a pat answer.

BECAUSE THERE IS NO PAT ANSWER.

Interviews for the unique KOTS volunteer crew start this week.

KOTS has provided bare essentials — a thin vinyl mat, a pink sheet and a towel and soap for the showers — for homeless men and women since 2004 at 5537 College Road.

The property is owned by the county, while the buildings belong to the city. Both remain defendants in a civil lawsuit filed in August by the Sunset Marina Condominium Association, which wants the shelter closed, citing the fact that the city bypassed all permits to hastily provide a place for the homeless to crash.

Recently restricted to holding only 140 people a night, a number that has been constant for weeks on end, the shelter has held 155 over the year.

“We just want to work with these people and give them some kind of hope that they could go back into normal society,” said Mayor Craig Cates, who just began his second term in office. “When they lose all hope there’s nothing left. We want to bring these people back into society.”

GOOD LUCK, MAYOR CATES.

Key West’s mayor is not only behind making big changes at KOTS, but he has made good on promises to strengthen law enforcement’s grasp when it comes to patrolling the island, home to a steady group of chronically homeless.

EVERY TIME THE MAYOR’S POLICE ROUST AWAKE A HOMELESS PERSON SLEEPING OUTSIDE ON A NIGHT KOTS IS FULL, THE MAYOR AND HIS POLICE VIOLATE THAT HOMELESS PERSON’S CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT NOT TO BE SUBJECTED TO CRUEL AND UNUSUAL PUNISHMENT, ACCORDING TO THE POTTINGER CASE.

In January, Cates plans to bring back before the City Commission a proposed ordinance to create “panhandling zones” in popular Old Town spots.

THIS IS THE ONLY SENSIBLE SUGGESTION THE CURRENT REGIME HAS MADE RE KEY WEST’S HOMELESS.

The idea is to force panhandlers to use a particular site for begging — one that is clearly marked for the public as well — to make it tougher on those who make a living collecting loose change and bills from tourists. Anyone caught panhandling outside of the zones, would face arrest.

This year, Cates’ proposals to toughen up two city laws that haunt the homeless — public camping and drinking — were approved by the commission.

A LAWSUIT WAITING TO BE FILED AGAINST THE CITY.

But when asked about KOTS moving into a transitional, even therapeutic model, Cates said he would consider asking the commission to hire the expert consultant Robert Marbut, who spoke in September about how other cities have greatly reduced homelessness by building comprehensive treatment centers.

ANYONE WHO ATTENDED MARBUT’S PRESENTATION AT OLD CITY HALL SHOULD HAVE KNOWN BY TIME HE WAS DONE HOLDING FORTH THAT HE HAD SERIOUSLY EXAGGERATED HIS SUCCESS RETURNING THE CHRONIC HOMELESS TO INDEPENDENT LIVING, AND THEY SHOULD HAVE KNOWN KEY WEST HAD NEITHER THE MONEY NOR THE LAND FOR THE KIND OF FACILITIES HARBUT USED IN OTHER CITIES. LET MAYOR CATES PAY HARBUT OUT OF HIS OWN POCKET.

Cates said he also values the ideas and opinions generated by the advisory council.

“They are more the experts than I am,” he said. “I listen to these people. What they do is more like a think tank.”

MAYOR CATES DOES NOT VALUE IS THE IDEAS OF REAL KEYS WEST HOMELESS EXPERTS, BECAUSE HE DOES NOT LIKE WHAT THEY HAVE TO SAY.

Cates said he isn’t concerned that the civil suit will shutter KOTS.

THE CITY WASN’T CONCERNED IT WOULD LOSE THE DUCK TOURS CASE, EITHER.

“It’s too important,” he said. “When we didn’t have KOTS, the homeless were camping all over town, out on the boulevard. Without having a shelter, you can’t make them leave that area. We have to have it, wherever it ends up being.”

MAYOR CATES PERCEIVED IMPORTANCE OF KOTS HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH DECIDING THAT LAWSUIT. THE CITY BUILT KOTS WITHOUT GAINING THE NECESSARY CITY, COUNTY, STATE AND FEDERAL APPROVALS. THE CITY IS ABOVE THE LAW?

IF MAYOR CATES EVER TELLS A KEY WEST NEIGHBORHOOD KOTS WILL BE RELOCATED IN THEIR BACK YARD, HE WILL FIND OUT PRONTO HE DID NOT GET A MANDATE IN THE LAST CITY ELECTIONS TO DO THAT. HE WILL FIND OUT PRONTO KEY WEST’S ONE HUMAN FAMILY CREED DOES NOT APPLY TO THE HOMELESS. HE MIGHT FIND OUT KEY WEST CITIZENS ARE NOT ABOVE TERRORIST RETALIATION AGAINST THEIR MAYOR AND HIS FAMILY, AND I DO NOT MEAN PAINTING UNPLEASANT STUFF ON OLD TOWN WALLS.

gfilosa@keysnews.com

THE MORE I READ IN THE CITIZEN ABOUT THE UNFOLDING KOTS SAGA, THE MORE I SEE THE BLIND, DEAF AND DUMB LEADING THE BLIND, DEAF AND DUMB. IT WOULD BE HILARIOUS, IF IT WERE NOT SO GRAVE.

DOROTHY SHERMAN, WHO STARTED THE SOUP KITCHEN AT MARY STAR OF THE SEA, WHO DEDICATED HER LATER LIFE TO SERVING HOMELESS, WHO WAS EULOGIZED AS A LIVING SAINT BY PETER BATTY AT HER WAKE AT MARY STAR OF THE SEA, MAINTAINED “IT IS OUR JOB TO FEED HOMELESS PEOPLE; IT IS GOD’S JOB TO CHANGE THEM.”
 
MANY TIMES I TOLD THE KEY WEST CITY COMMISSION IN OLD CITY HALL, ONLY GOD CAN CHANGE CHRONIC HOMELESS PEOPLE. I UNDERSTAND THAT IS NOT A MESSAGE MAINSTREAM LIKES TO HEAR, BUT IT IS SO NONETHELESS. THE CITY OF KEY WEST WOULD SERVE THE HOMELESS FAR BETTER BY CONCENTRATING ON HELPING THE NEW HOMELESS GET BACK ON THEIR FEET AND BACK INTO MAINSTREAM, AND BY STOPPING CITY POLICE FROM HUNTING DOWN AND ROUSTING HOMELESS PEOPLE OUT OF THEIR SLEEP WITH THREATS OF JAIL TIME IF THEY DON’T GET UP AND MOVE ON. KEY WEST’S POLICE HAVE FAR MORE SERIOUS CRIMES TO PREVENT THAN SOMEONE SLEEPING. I CAN’T HELP BUT WONDER WHAT JESUS WOULD SAY ABOUT THE POOR BEING CRIMINALIZED BECAUSE THEY SLEEP.
 
I usually can be reached at keysmyhome@hotmail.com.
 

fish for dinner

Saturday, December 24th, 2011

It’s been a very long time since I had a day off from writing for same day publication. Years. It also has been a long time since I had what I felt was a good Christmas. Maybe today will be better. Am having two new friends over to break bread at a late lunch. I met the younger couple earlier in the week. They drove up from Key West after we had exchanged these emails:

~I found your t-shirt in the thrift store [my 2009 Key West mayor's race capaign t-shirt, see home page of goodmorningkeywest.com]

And then decided to look into your campaign, and you. My girlfriend and I are recently arrived but maybe soon departing from your adopted home, KW. it seems as though very few people appreciate quality, truth, competence, integrity, personality, etc anymore, and have whole heartedly embraced mediocrity.

you seem different. my girlfriend and I would like to have a coffee or beer or something with you if you have the time and inclination. She, more than I, has suffered greatly from being real, and feels something going on your way. She’d also like to hear more about your time in Australia with the aborigines and your dreams and your inner spiritual journey.

our phone is 973-865-6247. She is presently pounding the pavement looking for that elusive bartender’s job, but we can meet up pretty much any time, if you have time, once you are done with your laundry.

Take care, good luck and hang in there with your endeavors. you aren’t crazy…..

Joe and Donia
Treewizard1@gmail.com

~You have more copies of that T-shirt than I. You two sound interesting. I live on Little Torch Key these days, but could drive down to KW to visit. Friday better for me than today or tomorrow. I like to hang out at Harpoon Harry’s. Perhaps late lunch while the morning shift, I call them my harem, still there. Here’s my landline, call me this evening or in the morning.

(305) 872-1705.

What is a tree wizard?

~you can have the TShirt when I leave the Keys. I ran into one of your supporters today at the health food store, so don’t lose faith. you have a secret underground army waiting in the wings, ready to give all, bear all, and bare all for the causes.

I would be happy to take a ride out to Little Torch to meet up if that is going to be easier than your coming here. I’d temporarily have to give up my coveted parking spot should I dare to move the car, but I wouldn’t mind at al getting off KW for a few hours, and it does seem a bit unseemly to worry about parking in Paradise…”. On the negative side, if we drive to you, I don’t get to meet your harem, and I’ve always wanted to know what a harem looks like…..

I’m giving your number to Donia, my partner, girlfriend, et al, to set things up. She is much more spiritual than I, or at least more articulate than I am about it. I prefer to chauffeur. And I am a tree wizard, an arborist, tree climber, and more…

We’ll talk soon!

Joe

Hi, Joe.

Maybe you have met Sandy Downs and her crew at Tarzan’s Tree Care? she used to be married to an aborist, who was Tarzan, climbed trees, and more …

What health food store, Help Yourself, I know Charley, Randesh and some of the other folks who hang out there, but didn’t know any were my secret followers, figured they thought I was seriously around any bends they could see on the horizon, although sometimes some of them come up here to be in nature for a while. I also know the owner of Sugar Apple, we have play some spirited chess games. He has a nice girlfriend.

Shortly after replying to you earlier today, wasn’t it?, it occurred to me that perhaps you two would like to get away from down there and come up here. Perhaps you’d like seeing my “farm” in the woods, and to meet my pet feral cat I got from the animal shelter down there because they said she was a varmint cat, which I sorely needed to live here due to big time woods rat community. First night she was in the trailer, Miss Kitty convened the rats for a prayer meeting with Jesus, and since then, they have stayed out of the inside of my abode, except for two or three very young ones who didn’t have better sense. Sometimes she treats me like one of the rats, sometimes she’s nice to me – a bit unpredictable lady, what’s new?

Spirituality is a nice name for mostly awful experiences, but if that were told straight out in the books that make authors rich and famous, or not, nobody would buy many of the books. I imagine that’s why so many people go to churches and retreats and to gurus and so forth instead. Count yourself fortunate you have a chauffer, and a lady one at that. You can meet my harem pretty easily I imagine by going into Harpoon Harry’s most any morning and telling the women servers Sloan sent you in there to meet his harem. Great bunch of ladies, they even put up with and sometimes even seem glad to see me come in there.

I await Donia’s call. Sort of sounds goddessy. Maybe she has a magic wand? I could use some help I hear often enough, feel in agreement usually, but not always with the precise help suggested. If you two arrive around meal time, there are some places nearby we can go that might not be up to Key West fare, but do in a pinch. Some of the harem around here, too. It’s a bit more rural up here than KW. Think almost redneck, but not entirely, except sometimes.

Sloan

 
So, Donia called and they drove up and we talked probably four hours, until maybe 1 a.m., then they headed back to their apartment on Duval Street. I had not had that kind of conversation with anyone in many years. They had spent a lot of time in jungles, they had been with shamans. They were very concerned with the destruction of this planet by people. They had found Key West very disappointing.
 
I told them when I first arrived in there in late 2000, the angels told me the city and the Keys are a powerful energy vortex like the Himalayas, the Andes and Sedona, caused in the Keys by the different seas and their currents rubbing against the limestone coral islands, the energy from which is drawn up through the Keys and Florida, all the way up into Canada. I said an energy vortex like that can produce all manner of extremes.
 
Around dawn yesterday morning, I dreamt of Donia, something we needed to do together. After waking, it occurred to me to call them to see if they wanted to have late Christmas lunch. Donia answered, said she thought Joe was somewhere watching football. She said they didn’t celebrate Christmas, but they would love to come back up. She had said the other night that she felt a hunger for fish. It occurred to me later that her hunger for fish might be deeper than just her belly. I said when I called her that I knew a young fisherman nearby, and I would see about getting fresh fish from him. Sandy Downs’ son Danny is a superb commercial fisherman. He loaded me up when I dropped by their home on Cudjoe Key last night. A bunch of meals worth now in plastic zip-lock bags in my freezer.
 
I have not cooked a meal for anyone else since the spring of 2006. I invited Sandy to join us. She asked if I had pots and pans and so forth? I raised an eyebrow, said yeah. She said she might come by but probably would not eat. I said sure, come to eat. She said maybe I didn’t remember how to cook after so long. I did the jerking off motion, said I hadn’t forgotten how to cook either, which created serious laughter among Sandy’s clan, but she probably wasn’t convinced I know how to cook. How many times have I eaten in her home, no way to remember them all, but not once has she eaten here.

I heard in dream just before rising last Sunday, “Something will happen next Sunday.” I awoke, realized that would be Christmas Day. Perhaps this meal with new friends, and perhaps with a brave old friend, is what was to happen today. Perhaps it is something else. Whatever, I imagine by tonight I might have a better grip on it.

Meanwhile, this younger couple look to me like they need some help fitting into Key West. He is an arborist, she says she is a terrific bartender, although i imagine she is plenty more than that, based on stories she told me about her own experiences with that which cannot be seen, heard or felt by normal human means. She said she speaks five languages. They conversed in French and Portugese (Brazilian) when they were with me.

The fish is the sign for Pices, Jesus was Pices. Maybe some day it will be recognized in Christendom that he was not born December 25, or even in December. Maybe some day other things about Jesus will be recognized in Christendom, like his teachings, which Donia said the other night do not apply today, but she has an urge to eat fish.

Well, perhaps that’s enough jabber for today, other than Joe and Donia meeting me, and vice versa, was clearly arranged by the angels, just as my meeting Sandy was just as clearly arranged by the angels, but I’ve told that story before.

I usually can be reached at keysmyhome@hotmail.com.

more bubba justice from Key West

Friday, December 23rd, 2011
 

Robert Krukto send me a copy of the sign-in sheets for the county jail on March 22, 2010, the day he was deposed by Michael Halpern, as described in yesterday’s post. Here’s what I wrote back:

Michael Halpern, Attorney, Alan Eckstein, Attorney, Mark Wilson (SAO) logged in consecutively on bottom of page 25, for “deposition”, “Krutko” and “deposition” in that order. At top of next page 26, John Evans logged in for “deposition,” then Scott Saunders signed logged in for “deposition”. A few lines down, a court reporter, name hard to make out, signed in for “deposition.”

They will have a tough time denying they were there that day. My opinion, Mark Wilson should have stopped the depostion when you said you didn’t have your court-appointed attorney there. Mark should have straightened out both Halpern and the deputies, who told you that you had to be deposed. I did not remember you telling me, nor writing back when, that Mark Wilson was there. But the log says he was.

Robert’s reply:

WAS DEATHLY SICK… I DONT REMEMBER MUCH ABOUT THE DAY EXCEPT THEY WERE ANTOGINIZING ME . WHO IS MARK WILSON?

My reply:

Mark Wilson is the Assistant State Attorney who had you extradited. I have written a number of times about what he told me about your case, why the State Attorney Office decided to help Judge Audlin enforce his contempt order. SAO beside Mark’s name on the jail log in means State Attorney Office.

Krutko’s reply:

OK HES FROM THE STATE ATTORNEYS OFFICE…. I WAS ILLEGALLY DEPOSED… REFUSED HELP WHEN WE BEGGED THE STATE ATTORNEYS OFFICE- AND AN ASST STATE ATTORNEY TOOK PART IN THE ILLEGAL DEPOSITIONS AND ARE YOU GOING TO TELL ME THATS OK?

NOW YOU SEE WHOS SIDE THE GREAT STATE ATTORNEY DENNIS WARD IS ON… THATS REAL DAMN DISGUSTING

In reply to something else I wrote to Krutko, lots of emails going both ways, this came back:

BUT YOU DIDNT ANSER MY QUESTION…

AN ILLEGAL DEPOSITION WAS DONE… AN ASST. STATE ATTORNEY WAS THERE AND STOOD BY AND DID NOTHING WHILE THEY AMBUSHED ME. ARE YOU TELLING ME THERE NOTING ILLEGAL AND UNETHICAL THERE?

My reply:

From what you wrote, the depostion was illegal to begin with because your court-appointed attorney was not there and was not noticed, and you said you didn’t want to do it with him not being there. I can’t imagine any judge I ever knew not jumping over the moon over that.

I don’t [think] Mark Wilson being there make it more illegal, but it aggravated the situation a bit. Sometimes I speak in understatement, to be sarcastic. Sometimes I speak more directly.

In PLAIN ENGLISH, based on your report of what happened, meaning, taking it as true, I was greatly disturbed to learn Mark Wilson was there and allowed it to go on.

Krutko’s reply:

SLOAN,

IM GOING TO LAY DOWN A SHORT BIT TO REST. BRETT SAID HE WASNT SHOCKED ABOUT THE ASST STATE ATTORNEY BEING AT THE ILLEGAL DEPOSITION JUST MORE DISGUSTED.

ROBERT

I DID GET A NICE E MAIL FROM AN ATTORNEY IN THE KEYS SAYING HE WAS SADDENED BY WHAT HAPPENED AND DISGUSTED AT THE PEOPLE INVOLVED. HE SAID IT WAS CLEARLY ILLEGAL BUT DIDNT WANT TO GET INVOLVED. HE SAID I SHOULD HAVE MY ATTORNEY ROE FILE A COMPLAINT WITH SOME JUDICIAL REVIEW BOARD. I SENT HIM BACK TELLING HIM THE ASST. STATE ATTORNEY WAS AT MY ILLEGAL DEPOSITION AND HE HASNT RESPONDED BACK YET.

Krutko is seriously ill, cancer.

Let me back up.

According to the docket sheet in the Clerk of Court’s office, Halpern filed suit on behalf of Fury Management, Inc., Scott Saunders, Michael Halpern, Alan Eckstein, John Evans and Chris Gardner against Robert Krutko on September 3, 2009, asking the court to enjoin Krukto from libeling the plaintiffs. Looking at the log-in record, all the plaintiffs but Chris Gardner logged in for Krukto’s deposition in the county jail.

 
Leading up to Halpern suing him, Krutko had filed regulatory agency complaints against Fury, a tour catamaran in which Halpern owned an interest. Krutko maintained all along Halpern sued him to shut him up about the Fury, not only about compliants with regulatory agencies, which took action against Fury, but also because Fury had gotten the boat slip used by the Krutkos tour boat and permission from the City of Key West to carry far more passengers than the City had allowed the Krutkos’ tour boat to use. In fact, the City had reduced the number of passengers Krutkos’ boat could use right after they bought it, which made it impossible for them to make money, which was the beginning of their troubles in Key West and the Keys. That was the basis for the Krutkos’ Duck Tours-ish later lawsuit against the City.
 
Now consider two pre-lawsuits Fury-related emails: 
From:Wheezy9870@aol.com [mailto:Wheezy9870@aol.com]
Sent: 05/16/2007 12:18 PM
To:
info@keywestinfo.com
Subject: key west
 

ATTENTION ALL BUSINESS OWNERS/MANAGERS,

KEY WEST ALLOWS ILLEGAL HOTEL MARINA WITH ILLEGAL ACTIVITIES ALSO GOING ON THERE

THE OCEAN KEY RESORT AT 0 DUVAL HAS OFFICIALS LOOKING THE OTHER WAY.THEY WERE ALSO CAUGHT TODAY WITH WELL OVER 100 EXTRA SEATS ON THEIR PIER JOHN JONES IGNORES.

IN THIS E MAIL AT THE BOTTOM OF MY EMAIL HERE YOU WILL SEE THE CITY CODE ENFORCEMENT (JENSEY PROBST) CLEARLY SEES THE ILLEGAL MARINA OPERATIONS GOING ON. MOST OF YOU WHO OWN/RUN BUSINESSES ARENT ALLOWED TO BE ILLEGAL AND MUST OBEY CITY LAWS. HOW COME A CERTAIN SMALL FEW GET AWAY WITH ILLEGAL ACTIVITIES WHILE OTHERS ARE FORCED TO OBEY THE LAWS? BUSINESS OWNERS WHO ARE NOT PART OF THE BIG BUBBAS (LIKE HALPERN FURY PARTNER) AND HIS SIDE KICK PUPPET SCOTT SAUNDERS KNOW WHAT ITS LIKE TO HAVE TO RUN A BUSINESS LEGALLY. THE FURY AFTER OUR COMPLAINT OF OPERATING THEIR NEW BUSINESS AT 0 DUVAL WITHOUT A LICENSE WAS CITED AND FINED FOR THIS. INSTED OF NOT GETTING A LICENSE ,AFTER THIS VIOLATION THE CITY GAVE THEM AN OCCUPATIONAL LICENSES THE SAME DAY. (HMMMMM)

From: scott saunders <stllc@bellsouth.net>
To: Wheezy9870 <
Wheezy9870@aol.com>
Cc: info <
info@keywestinfo.com>
Sent: Wed, May 16, 2007 4:24 pm
Subject: RE: key west

Robert,

Just want to say thanks for all your doing for the city of Key West and Fury. All of your hard work is truly making it a better place for all of us.

If you ever want to come out on the Fury and experience a first class operation, please let me know.

Hope your having a great day!

Once again, thanks.

Fury Side Kick Puppet

Yes, this is the same Scott Saunders who later sued Robert Krutko, was at the deposition, a side-kick puppet indeed.

From all I have seen, it looks to me like Robert Krutko and his family got screwed all the way around. Also looks to me like Krutko might have gotten a very different result, if he had not launched his Internet war.

++++++++++++++++++++
 
Also on the westerly most Key, this report from the inadvertent institgator of the “war of the painted wall” which is getting pretty good coverage in The Citizen (keysnews.com) lately … 
In Key West a Cuban Immigrant is Interviewed at the Wall of Shame & Freedom on Virginia and Watson Street
 
I must apologize for this whole Defend Virginia Street thing getting out of hand, and soon becoming an international incident.(CNN was here this morning) I only wanted to save a wall, a few trees and make people aware of the Injustices involved here on Virginia Street. Asking the Artists to paint the wall was just a prank on our radio show, when over 60 people showed up we were amazed. Some of the art was Quite Remarkable. But Now it is gone – I still can not conceive why if the wall was to be torn down, this would be such a problem, In the Facebook Pictures and Youtube Videos you all used against my wife as evidence – (BTW – those weren’t even the people doing the tagging) My wife Sherrie was actually covering over the Profanity used against Commissioner Teri Johnston’s comment on that You tube video… “Mrs. Hell” is now pissed off about the Sheriff coming to her work and threatening to put her in jail, and is comparing all of this to the movie “Alice’s Restaurant” by Arlo Guthrie – whom is actually a friend of ours! How would each of you feel – if we had you hauled of to jail from a city council meeting, in front of your friends and co-workers?I have asked the artists and neighbors to stop tagging the wall …all day yesterday -but after the city “white washed” the fence. They have taken this has a declaration of war, I was up till 2 in the morning last night telling people that the property was under surveillance by KWPD – and when I awoke they had tagged the wall again. I would go out and paint it over my self – but when the city was here they confiscated all of my Paint, Brushes and Paint tools…. Along with Removing all the Christmas and Halloween Decorations that my daughter had up. I can no longer help you any more – I’m sorry! If that wall at Virginia and Watson Street is City Property- then why don’t we just leave it there?…and call it a community wall !No one on Virginia Street wanted a new Sidewalk – and we said that at every meeting we attended.
 
I strongly suggest all of you READ this !

http://flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2011/95.16

It’s a State Wide Law!

*Personally, I have nothing against any of you… only the way you conduct “business” – that so effects the lives of others. And thus infringes on this Historic Island Paradise we all Call HOME !

PLEASE Don’t Lose our History.

Have Not a Merry Christmas – such as I.

May the Peace Be With You…..and Yours! One Human Family?

Gary W. Ek

Reverend Gweko aka the “SOUNDMAN FROM HELL”

 
In old town Key West – Those trees on Virginia Street had seen their share of storms. They were strong and healthy. But One Late Fall morning -They Were NO Match to a Chainsaw at the Hands of Progress. I could see removing it if it were rotted or diseased but not simply because it was in the way. The city wants to spend money on the new sidewalks which will end up costing the taxpayers some serious cash.
 
No One Really Wants A Historical Paradise Island to become civilized do they???

Here is a Video Tour Of Virginia Street – Before its History was Lost for ever! Keep Our Historic City Historic -

 
Defend Virginia Street Meeting at the Key West Firehouse Museum with Karen Olson and David Fernandez from the City of Key West – and the Residents of Virginia Street. November 16th 2011 Edited and Audio Enhanced by Gary W. Ek for Key West Show
www/.
keywestshow.com
 
 
On same topic from a Cudjoe Key amiga yesterday:

Dear Sloan, I have been in a dispute with the Tree Commission over their refusal to sign an emergency permit for a tree take down that had caused a loss of 251,000 gallons of water. I also trimmed a tree as legally required as a “duty of the homeowner” and removed rotten limbs that were falling on the sidewalk, on parked cars and hitting vehicles passing by. I removed the branches hiding traffic signs and ones that had become entangled with the cable and telephone lines. All cuts were made to arborist standards and legal requirements and “duties of the Homeowner” were met with this trimming. I received violations for both: taking a tree down in an emergency, and for making a tree safe for pedestrians and motorists as legally required. I believe these are in retaliation for my outspoken disapproval of the Tree Commission’s practice of converting commercial and City rules unlawfully to include private properties so they can extort money from private citizens in fees and fines.

My research led me to find these things:

1. The Virginia Street project appears to have been voted on illegally. The City Commission voted to approve this project in 2010, over 1 yr PRIOR to the Tree Commission’s approval on Nov 14, 2011. It is against City Ordinances for the City Commission to vote on sidewalk plans that have not yet been approved by the following departments in this order:

#1. Landscape Dept.

#2. Tree Commission

#3. Planning and then…

#4. City Commission

The City Commission could not have legally voted on this matter until after the Tree Commission approved the plans on November 14th 2011, and then Planning needed to approved them before the item could legally be put on the agenda for City Commission to vote on. So any vote prior to the end of November this year should be disregarded as being in violation of the Ordinances.

2. The Tree Commission gave the wrong date in the notice to the Virginia Street citizens as to when the Hearing would take place involving the Virginia Street tree removals. This improperly dated Notice caused them to miss the meeting and denied them their right to give public input. Therefore, the Tree Commission vote was improper, denied citizens their rights to be heard, and the trees should never have been removed at all.

3. The Statute of Limitations ran out 23 years ago for the City to “just take the wall and 6 feet of property back” on Virginia Street, and if the City does not pay the owner the just value, it will be an “illegal taking” and will violate the 5th Amendment in the Bill of Rights.

4. The ADA standards for sidewalks is 36? with passing zones every 200 feet. The Virginia Street sidewalk IS 36? and all that needed to be done was create the proper passing zones, slopes and curbs. The Citizen was incorrect in reporting ADA standards was 4 ft, it is 3ft.

And the Assistant City Manager Dave Fernandez was either incompetent or dishonest when he said in the Firehouse meeting with Virginia Street residents that the ADA requirements were too difficult and confusing for him to explain; meanwhile telling the residents the trees had to come down, walls and property had to be taken, and their parking spaces would be substantially diminished.

5. Criminal mischief charges were wanted against those who had painted the wall the City says it owns, yet, I understand the City made the “owner” of this wall apply and pay for the permit to remove it.

I will keep you informed of anything more I find out, but it seems the City is stepping into some messy and expensive business here of property and civil rights, all for a sidewalk project that may have been illegally voted on,prior to a Tree Commission hearing that was improperly noticed. Not only that, but if the above is correct, the City has also whitewashed a wall it does not own, defamated the character of both Gary Ek and his wife, and taken beloved trees down without cause or a proper hearing.

Sandra Downs …your faithful co-dependent Gadfly
 
Looks to me like a case for Last Stand, Mother Nature’s advocate agency in the Keys.
 
Slightly related is the lead article in this week’s edition of Key West the Newspaper (kwtnblue.com):
 
December 23rd, 2011

PAGE ONE COMMENTARY: A Mangrove Massacre, Bogus Permits and Other City Landscape Scandals

WHY WOULD A CITY CREW TAKE A BACKHOE TO “TRIM” SOME MANGROVES?

THE CONTROVERSIAL VIRGINIA STREET SIDEWALK AND TREE-CUTTING PROJECT MAY BE ILLEGAL

by Sandy Downs
The City’s Urban Landscape Department was responsible for the Mangrove Massacre on Fogarty Street, the traumatic tree removals on Virginia Street, and now they, in conjunctionwith the Tree Commission, have told lies to the public regarding “trimming“ your trees. All of this has been accomplished under the new department head, Karen DeMaria, in only a few short months. What more is to come and how much is the public willing to take?
Well, hold onto your seats.

Mangrove Massacre

Karen DeMaria, head of Urban Landscape Department, is supposed to issue the work orders and supervise the work of city landscaping crews. She has said it was a “mistake” that a crew took a backhoe and ripped out all the mangroves lining the water’s edge on Fogarty Street. Now we await to see what fines State Department of Environment Protection will impose and what the City taxpayers will have to pay for this “mistake.” 
Lies to the Public
For years, the Tree Commission has been selling permits to homeowners who wanted to trim tree limbs more than 3 1/2 in diameter. The cost of those permits has been $150 per caliper (diameter)— or $525. These permits have probably produced millions of dollars for the Tree Commission and the city over the years.
So would you be surprised to learn that there is no such tree-trimming law in Key West? Well, there isn’t! That is what Tree Commission Chairman Neils said during a Tree Commission meeting just two weeks ago. And in a recent article in the Key West Citizen, Karen DeMaria was quoted as saying the same thing.
So if citizens are not required to have a permit to trim their trees, what has happened to all that money? Will the citizens who paid for for those bogus permits now get their money back? Is this simply extortion by the government? I have asked State Attorney Dennis Ward to look into this.

Virginia Street Sidewalk Project

Now, are you ready for this one? It appears the entire Virginia Street Sidewalk Project may be illegal. The City Commissioners voted on the sidewalk project in 2010, well before the Tree Commission had approved the plans— and that violates city ordinances. The vote should not have come before the City Commission until these things had taken place:
• Urban Landscape Department submits the plans for the sidewalks and tree take-downs.
• Tree Commission approves them in a public meeting.
• The approved plans go to the Planning Department for approval
• The Planning Department sends them to the City Commission for a vote and approval
Well, the City Commission voted on this in 2010, but the Tree Commission didn’t approve the plans until just a month ago in the meeting on Monday November 14.
The City Commissioners were literally “out of line” in voting on this prior to November 14. So the vote from 2010 should be made null and void, because any vote taken prior to November 14, 2011, was not following proper and legal procedure.
So, what will come of all of this? I don’t know, but I have tried to do my part. I have e-mailed the appropriate government officials asking that the work on Virginia Street be stopped until the legality of the project is settled. And I have asked that both DeMaria and Weise be removed fron their positions.

I urge you to get involved and call the Commissioners and tell them you expect more from your public officials. Also, if you have an interest in what the Tree Commission has been doing to private citizens, please contact me by e-mail at janesjunglework@gmail.com or call 305-395-2302

 
EDITOR’S NOTE: Sandra Downs is a longtime activist here. If her name sounds familiar, that may be because she ran for Sheriff in the last county elections. She owns Tarzan Tree Care.
 
++++++++++++++++++++++++
 

I usually can be reached at keysmyhome@hotmail.com, but this being the day before Christmas, I might go down to Key West to visit with my Harem at Harpoon Harry’s and get whomped by my good friend and chess teacher Patrick the Terminator and see the old Virginia Street trees which might not see another Christmas …

heinous – Krutko, plus new school district intrigue

Friday, December 23rd, 2011

At the end of today’s further delving into the Krutko affair is former school district Audit & Finance Committee (AFC) member Larry Murray’s expose of recent intrigue on the AFC, about which you may or may not get the same perspective from the AFC, the school district, the school board, The Citizen or the Keynoter.
 
A Key West fellow on my email hit list pointed out yesterday that I been spelling Krutko, Krukto. My apologies. Received this yesterday from Robert Krutko:
 
SLOAN,
 
AFTER MY BOAT WAS STOLEN AND THE F.W.C. STATE POLICE WERE ON THE SCENE AND ALLOWED AN INDIVIDUAL TO COME FROM KEY WEST AND WITHOUT ANY PAPERWORK AT ALL TAKE A 200K BOAT AND HOTWIRE IT IN FRONT OF A STATE POLICE OFFICER AND NO QUESTIONS WERE ASKED. I CALLED THE F.W.C.’S MAIN OFFICE MAD ASS HELL AND WANTED ANSWERS. I FINALLY WENT TO THEIR BOARD MEMBERS WHICH ARE MEMBERS APPOINTED BY THE GOVERNOR HIMSELF. ONE SUCH MEMBER WAS KATHY BARCO. PHONE LOGS CAN EASILY BE GOTTEN TO PROVE WE SPOKE WITH THE TIME AND DATE.
 
I WAS ALREADY BLOGGING ABOUT THE OFFICER AND ALLOWING AN EXPENSIVE BOAT LIKE THIS TO BE TAKEN WITHOUT PROOF OF OWNERSHIP. I TOLD KATHY BARCO HER BOARD SHOULD GET INVOLVED AND HELP. SHE ASKED ME IF I WAS THE ONE WHO POSTED ABOUT THE OFFICER AND HER AGENCY I SAID YES. SHE GOT VERY IRATE AND WE HAD A SHOUTING MATCH. AT THE END SHE SAID IF I BLOGGED ABOUT HER AND HURT HER FAMILYS BUSINESS REPUTATION ( BARCO DUVAL ENGINEERING) I WOULDNT LIVE TO REGRET IT THEN SHE HUNG UP.
 
THE CALL I MADE WAS TO HER COMPANY. WITHIN ABOUT 5 MINUTES OR SO AFTER HER THREATS AND HANGING UP HER BROTHER BARRY BARCO WICH WAS IN HER OFFICE ON SPEAKER PHONE DURING OUR CALL SENT ME AN E MAIL. AGAIN MY CALL WITH TIMES AND DATES CAN BE GOTTEN IM SURE FROM THE PHONE COMPANY.
 
HERE IS HIS E MAIL AND YES IT CAN BE SHOWN EASILY IT WAS FROM THEIR CORPORATE COMPUTER… 
—–Original Message—–From: Barry <bbarco@barcoduval.com>
To: wheezy9870 <wheezy9870@aol.com
>
Sent: Thu, Oct 30, 2008 3:29 pm
Subject: RE: KATHY BARCO SUPPORTS CRIMINALS

Sleep with one eye open

 
Also from Krutko yesterday:
 
CAPT. RICHARD BLOCK OF THE NATIONAL MARINERS ASSOCIATION HAS BEEN FOLLOWING MY CASE FOR SEVERAL YEARS. HERE IS A WRITEUP HE DID ON MY CASE..
 
http://www.investigativeblogger.com/2010/12/robert-krutko-government-corruption.html
 
A long article, I pulled from it what was reported about Robert Krutko being held in contempt of court in Key West, and what happened to him thereafter: arrest, jail in Ohio, extradition, medical emergency, jail in Key West, and a jail house depostion of Krukto by Key West Attorney Michael Halpern, allegedly without the knowledge or permission of Krukto’s court-appointed lawyer and against Krukto’s wishes, while he allegedly was under pressure from deputies to do the deposition, with several of Halpern’s plaintiffs present.
 
++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 
Two months after the Cochran Law Firm filed a notice of suit against the City of Key West, on Sept. 11, 2009 Monroe County 16th Judicial Circuit Judge David Audlin issued an injunction for protection and temporary restraining order on behalf of Fury Management, Inc, and local attorneys Michael Halpern, and Alan Eckstein, and John Evans (local jet-ski operator and alleged boat thief) and others against “Robert M. Krutko, his agents, servants, employees, and all persons in active concert and participation with him to cease, desist, directly or indirectly, sending any electronic mail and electronic communication” against the operators of the “Fury” concession.(1) [(1)Case #09-CA-001494-K.] .
 
Robert described some of his blogging to me on occasion, but I had neither the time nor inclination to engage in blogging individually or on behalf of our Association. On occasion, I received copies via e-mail but neither contributed to nor encouraged this method of expression. Nevertheless, as our Association’s Editor, I am convinced that the Constitution expresses freedom of expression in any form including electronic and that libel laws are in place to protect individuals and corporate entities against statements that are proven to be false.

[NMA Comment: Judge Audlin ordered Robert Krutko, who lives near Columbus, Ohio, to appear in his courtroom in Key West. Robert did not appear to answer these charges. As a result, the Judge ordered him extradited from Ohio to answer the charges against his ”blogging” activities. He was incarcerated for approximately 6 months in Ohio and Florida. That adventure is described “in his own words.”]

[NMA Comment: Robert Krutko blew the whistle on “Fury Management, Inc.” for operating illegally on state bay-bottom leased property which he discovered during his inquiry. The Florida Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) found the complaints valid and fined Fury Management and Ocean Key Resort to protect wildlife reserve property. In retribution, Fury and others filed suit against Krutko to silence him and deny him use of the internet.]

The Extradition Experience In His Own Words

In mid-November 2010, Robert Krutko responded by e-mail to a number of our questions regarding his business background and his extradition experience. We organized these replies with subtitles and edited this section for clarity and major grammar and punctuation. Robert was in poor health throughout this period and reported being diagnosed with a mass on his lung and liver [maglignant].

 Past Business ResumeI have owned and operated a number of small businesses from hot dog carts to food establishments to building my own sports bar from ground up which I sold for a profit.

I then entered into the pressure washing business and started from nothing and built it from ground up to one of the largest residential pressure washing companies in Ohio.I was doing in excess of 250,000 plus per year and got burned out after about ten years and over 45,000 washes completed. I did state contracts, county contracts as well as residential washing. I even had the city of Columbus trash truck contract which we washed weekly – there were many trucks. I did the Franklin County courts parking garage once a year including all City of Columbus school buses which were done once a year over a 2 week period getting them ready for their yearly inspections by the state troopers.

I took my wife to Key West once because I went there as a kid with my parents. We decided to invest in a house outside Key West and open a business so we could get it going then when my kids graduated from high school move there full time and live. This was all stolen from us.

Columbus, Ohio 

TO THE FEW OF YOU WHO HAVE BEEN TRYING TO HELP MY FAMILY THANK YOU.

BELOW IS A SUMMARY THAT HAUNTS ME DAILY AND NIGHTLY I WANT TO PUT IN WRITING SO EVERYONE KNOWS WHAT I’VE BEEN THROUGH.

IN EARLY NOVEMBER 2009 I WAS SURROUNDED BY F.B.I. AND COLUMBUS POLICE AND CUFFS PUT ON MY HANDS WHICH I NEVER EXPERIENCED BEFORE. AFTER TAKEN DOWNTOWN, THE F.B.I. TRIED TO QUESTION ME BUT I ALWAYS SAW ON T.V. NEVER ANSWER QUESTIONS UNLESS YOU HAVE AN ATTORNEY, SO I DIDN’T. 

AFTER BEING TAKEN TO A HOLDING CELL I WAS STILL IN SHOCK BUT WAS LATER TAKEN TO DORM. I REMEMBER CALLING MY WIFE REGULARLY BECAUSE NOT ONLY WAS I SCARED I NEVER WAS AFFORDED A TOOTH BRUSH FOR AT LEAST A COUPLE WEEKS MAYBE MORE. LATER AFTER BEING TAKEN TO COURT SEVERAL TIMES, I WAS INTRODUCED TO SHACKLES IN WHICH I HAD TO WEAR TO AND FROM COURT INCLUDING IN COURT.

THE ONLY THING I COULD THINK OF IS I WISH I WAS DEAD – THIS CANT BE HAPPENING TO ME.EACH TIME WE WERE TAKEN TO COURT WE WERE ALL TOLD BY DEPUTY’S TO KEEP YOUR MOUTH SHUT AND DO NOT TALK TO THE JUDGE OR WE “WILL YANK YOU OUT OF THE COURT”. WOW, I THOUGHT WE CANT TELL A JUDGE OUR STORY….

I REMEMBER ONE DAY BEING TAKEN OFF THE BUS AND WHILE IN CUFFS AND SHACKELS ENTERING THE JAIL THERE WERE 3-4 DEPUTYS WHICH WOULD GREET THE COURT BUS LOAD TO REMOVE CUFFS ETC. ONE OLDER DEPUTY I REMEMBER YELLING OUT “WHAT IN THE HELL IS THIS MAN (ME) DOING IN SHACKELS. AFTER LOOKING AT MY PAPERWORK AND ASKING ME WHY I WAS THERE, I TOLD HIM IT WAS A CIVIL CASE THAT STEMMED INTO FUGATIVE FROM JUSTICE, I REMEMBER HIM TELLING DEPUTYS “GET THE DAMN CUFFS AND SHACKELS OFF THIS MAN” AND ALSO SAID “WHO IN THE HELL PUT THEM ON HIM TO BEGIN WITH. I WANTED SO MUCH TO HUG THIS MAN AND TELL HIM THANK YOU BUT I DIDNT.( BUT I DID SMILE AND THINK TO MYSELF THIS GUYS SEES THE B.S. GOING ON HERE)ONE OTHER INCIDENT I STILL SEE EVERY DAY AND NIGHT AND CAN EVEN SMELL YET TODAY WILL SHOCK SOME OF YOU BUT ALTHOUGH I’M IN TEARS RIGHT NOW I FEEL I NEED TO TELL IT.I WAS PUT INTO A HOLDING CELL NEAR THE FRONT DOORS OF THE JACKSON PIKE ENTRANCE TO THE JAIL. I CANNOT REMEMBER WHY I WAS THERE BUT THERE WERE 3 OF US IN THERE. THIS IS A SMALL CELL WITH ICE COLD BLOWING AIR ON YOU AND YOU ARE PUT IN WITH BARELY NO CLOTHES ON ITS ABOUT 30-40 DEGREES IN THERE. ANYWAY ONE DAY WHILE I WAS SLEEPING, AND THE OTHERS ON THE ICE COLD FLOOR SLEEPING I HEARD A LOUD RUMBLE AND GURGLE.

WHEN I AWOKE THE OTHER 2 INMATES WERE POUNDING FOR GUARDS WHICH THERE WERE ATLEAST 5 AT THE DESK ONLY 50 FEET AWAY. THE GURGLEING WAS A TOILET OVERFLOWING AT ABOUT 2 FEET HIGH, NON-STOP OF URINE AND FECES.

THE SMELL WAS VERY BAD. AS I AWOKE WITH 2 OTHER INMATES YELLING FOR HELP GUARDS WERE WALKING BY LAUGHING SAYING “HEY YOU PIECES OF SHIT, DEAL WITH IT” …

WITHIN A COUPLE MINUTES WE WERE COVERED IN URINE AND FECES WITH ABOUT 3? INCHES ON THE FLOOR. ONE INMATE TOLD US TO TAKE OFF OUR BLANKETS (WHICH IS KIND OF STIFF AND USED IT TO PUSH THE URINE AND FECES OUTSIDE UNDER THE DOOR INTO THE MAIN LOBBY WHERE THE GUARDS WERE SO WE DID.)

AFTER THEY SAW THIS, THEY FINALLY UNLOCKED THE DOORS AND GOT INMATES TO MOP THE FLOOR. BY THIS TIME OUR FEET-AND SIDES OF OUR BODYS FROM SLEEPING ON THE FLOOR WERE COVERD IN THIS MESS. THEY REMOVED US INTO INDIVIDUAL CELLS WHERE WE WERE MADE TO EAT- AND SLEEP WITH NO SOAP OR NOT EVEN ALLOWED TO WASH UP. THIS LASTED FOR ABOUT A WEEK.

I WILL SAY THE ONE THING THAT KEPT ME GOING DURING THIS WAS MY TWO VISITATION DAYS IN COLUMBUS JAIL WHERE MY WIFE NEVER MISSED A VISIT AND SITTING ON THAT CHAIR LOOKING THROUGH A GLASS AND TALKING THROUGH A HOLE TO MY BEAUTIFUL WIFE IS SOMETHING I’LL NEVER FORGET.

AS YOU CAN SEE THIS IS BAD AND JUST A SMALL PART OF WHAT IVE BEEN THROUGH.

Extradition from Columbus, Ohio to Key West

WHEN I LEFT COLUMBUS OHIO JAIL AND WAS SHOVED INTO A 1 TON VAN LOADED WITH PRISONERS AND NO ROOM TO EVEN MOVE WE MADE MANY STOPS DOWN TO FLORIDA.

WE DROPPED PRISONERS OFF AND PICKED UP BOTH MEN AND WOMEN. WE STAYED AT SEVERAL JAILS OVERNIGHT SO THE TRANSPORT PEOPLE COULD SLEEP.

ON MY LAST DROP OFF, THE EXTRADITION PEOPLE TOLD ME I WOULD NOT BE PICKED UP BECAUSE I WAS GOING TO BE TRANSPORTED SOME OTHER WAY.

THEY WOULD NOT TELL ME WHEN OR HOW BUT SAID I WAS ON HOLD AND IT WAS SOMEWHERE CLOSE TO BROOKSVILLE, FLORIDA.

THAT NIGHT OF BEING IN JAIL AND NOT KNOWING WHEN I WAS GOING TO LEAVE I WAS VERY ILL. FINALLY LATER THAT DAY OTHER PRISONERS SAW I WAS SICK AND COULDN’T EAT AND POUNDED ON OUR DOOR TO GET THE GUARDS.

THE GUARD SHOWED UP AND THEY TOOK ME TO THE JAIL NURSE. SHE CHECKED MY VITALS AND SAID I SHOULD SIT OUT IN THE MAIL HALL BY THE GUARDS TOWER AND GET SOME FRESH AIR AND IF I GOT WORSE, ASK FOR HER. A WHILE LATER I GOT VERY BAD AND SHE SAW ME AGAIN .

AFTER BEING CHECKED AGAIN, SHE SAID I WAS VERY PALE AND MY VITALS WERE ALL OVER THE PLACE SO SHE MADE A PHONE CALL AND TOLD WHOMEVER I NEEDED AN AMBULANCE. MY CHEST WAS HURTING AND IT WAS HARD TO BREATHE. AN AMBULANCE CAME, AND I WAS SHACKLED AND CHAINED TO THE GURNEY WITH DEPUTY’IES FOLLOWING IN SQUAD CARS.

WHEN WE GOT TO THE HOSPITAL, THE DOCTOR LADY COME INTO MY ROOM AND TOLD ME AND THE GUARD I WAS GOING TO BE ADMITTED FOR FURTHER TESTS. HE CALLED THE EXTRADITION TRANSPORT PEOPLE TO NOTIFY THEM IT WAS THEIR JOB TO GET SOMEONE TO GUARD ME WHILE I WAS IN THE HOSPITAL.

WHEN I GOT SET IN MY ROOM, THE GUARDS WERE ROTATING 12 HOUR SHIFTS AND MOST COMING FROM THE EAST COAST OF FLORIDA. MOST WERE NICE, BUT ONE HEAVY SET JACKASS WAS KIND OF RUDE.

ONE DAY WHEN THE DOCTOR CAME IN TO GET ME UNCHAINED FROM THE BED TO MOVE ME FOR EXAMS, THE JACKASS COULDN’T GET THE SHACKLES OFF MY LEGS AND HIS KEYS DIDN’T WORK.

HE ASKED IF I COULD JUST BE MOVED IN MY BED AND THE DOCTOR SAID NO WAY BECAUSE IF THERE WAS AN EMERGENCY WHERE I HAD TO BE PUT ON ANOTHER TABLE ETC THEY COULDN’T DO IT.

THEY CALLED HOSPITAL MAINTENANCE TO SEE IF THEY COULD CUT THE CUFFS AND SHACKLES OFF ME AND THEY DIDN’T. T HEY CALLED THE LOCAL SHERIFF FROM THE JAIL AND DEPUTY’S CAME OVER WITH THEIR KEYS TO SEE IF THEY WOULD WORK; AND THEY DIDN’T.

AT THIS TIME A SWEET NURSE WHO WAS WATCHING THIS ALL TOLD THE JACKASS GUARD THIS WAS INHUMANE AND UNSAFE AND HOW HE COULD CHAIN SOMEONE UP AND NOT BE ABLE TO GET THEM OUT.

I EVEN THINK THE FIRE DEPARTMENT WAS CALLED AND FINALLY SOMEONE WHOM I CAN’T REMEMBER BROKE ME FREE. THE HOSPITAL NURSES AND DOCTORS APOLOGIZED.

ONE OF THE OTHER EXTRADITION OFFICERS WHOM I MENTIONED EARLIER THAT WAS NICE, ALLOWED ME TO USE HIS PERSONAL CELL PHONE ON VALENTINE’S DAY AND MY BIRTHDAY TO CALL MY WIFE WHICH I KNOW HE WASN’T SUPPOSED TO DO. BUT HE REALIZED BY THE TRANSPORT PAPERWORK I WAS NOT A THREAT AND THIS WAS A JOKE…

ALL THIS CAN BE DOCUMENTED BY THE HOSPITAL WHICH IM PRETY SURE WAS BROOKVILLE GENERAL IN BROOKVILLE FLORIDA..

Jail in Key West

AFTER BEING EXTRADITED TO KEY WEST, I WAS PUT IN A MEDICAL LOCKDOWN FOR AT LEAST SEVERAL WEEKS. I WAS TOLD ONE DAY I WAS GOING TO BE PUT INTO GENERAL POPULATION. I WAS TAKEN TO GENERAL POPULATION IN THE MIDDLE OF THE NIGHT SO EVERYONE WAS ASLEEP.

THAT NEXT MORNING AT BREAKFAST, SEVERAL MEN APPROACHED ME AS I WAS GETTING JUICE AND ONE ASKED ME IF I WAS THE INFAMOUS KRUTKO THATS BEEN POSTING ON THE INTERNET AGAINST HALPERN, EVANS AND OTHER BUSINESS OWNERS. WHEN I TURNED TO ASK WHO WAS ASKING THEY WALKED AWAY.

WITHIN AN HOUR A GROUP OF GUYS FORMED TOGETHER AT THE BACK OF THE DORM YELLING STUFF TO ME LIKE “KRUTKO IS A DEAD MAN.”

THEY WERE ALSO YELLING” EVERYONE FILL YOUR SOCKS WITH SOAP, HE’S NOT GOING TO GET THROUGH THE NIGHT.”

A GUARD I BELIEVE NAMED KIP HEARD THE YELLS AND I FILED A WRITTEN REQUEST TO HIM AT THIS SAME TIME FOR PROTECTIVE CUSTODY WHICH HE HAD GUARDS COME AND GET ME.

FOR THOSE OF YOU THAT DON’T KNOW, IN KEY WEST PROTECTIVE CUSTODY IS IN THE SAME LOCK DOWN DORM AS THE WORST OFFENDERS.

YOU STAY LOCKED DOWN 24-7 AND ONLY ALLOWED TO GET OUT 3 DAYS A WEEK FOR 1 HOUR.

THIS TIME IS TO BE USED FOR RECREATION, SHOWERS, AND PHONE CALLS. CALLS HERE ARE ABOUT $5 PER MINUTE. THE CELL IS ABOUT 5’ X 7’….

SEVERAL OTHERS WHO I KNEW WERE OUTSIDE AND ON MY SIDE WERE ALSO ON MY MIND DAILY AND HELPED ME BE STRONG…

I REMEMBER ONE OF THE EXTRADITION OFFICERS STAYING IN MY ROOM AT THE HOSPITAL AND WISHED ME HAPPY BIRTHDAY. HE WAS A RETIRED COP WORKING FOR THIS COMPANY WHEN NEEDED AND APOLOGIZED SINCE I WAS BEING CHAINED LIKE THIS FOR THE B.S. CASE. .

HE ALSO LET ME USE HIS CELL PHONE SEVERAL TIMES INCLUDING MY BIRTHDAY TO CALL MY WIFE BECAUSE HE SAW HOW UPSET I WAS. HE WAS A GREAT GUY JUST LIKE BRETT….

DURING MY JAIL TIME, WITHIN A MONTH BEFORE I BONDED OUT, I WAS CALLED BY A GUARD THAT CAME INTO OUR DORM. HE YELLED “KRUTKO” IN WHICH I GOT UP AND ANSWERED HIM. HE TOLD ME YOU HAVE A VISITOR IN WHICH I WAS CONFUSED BUT FIGURED IT MAY BE AN ATTORNEY ON MY BEHALF OR CAPT AL, A FRIEND OF MINE IN KEY WEST. WHEN I ASKED THE GUARD ON THE WAY DOWN THE HALL WHO IT WAS HE KEPT SAYING, “I DONT KNOW.”

Forced Deposition Without Legal Representation

I WALKED INTO A ROOM WITH 5-6 INDIVIDUALS, A COURT REPORTER, AND SEVERAL GUARDS I BELIEVE WERE SERGEANTS..

THEY TOLD ME TO SIT AT A DESK IN FRONT OF A MAN LOOKING AT ME. THE MAN ASKED IF I KNEW WHO HE WAS I SAID “NO” BECAUSE AT THIS TIME I WAS VERY WEAK AND JUST DIDN’T RECOGNIZE HIM. HE SAID. “MY NAME IS MICHAEL HALPERN AND I’M HERE TO DEPOSE YOU.”

I TOLD HIM MY ATTORNEY APPOINTED TO ME DIDN’T MAKE ME AWARE OF THIS AND HE SAID HE WROTE JOE VREDEVELT A LETTER AND JOE SAID HE WASNT REPRESENTING ME BUT TREAT ME WITH RESPECT. I TOLD HALPERN A COURT APPOINTED ATTORNEY WAS PROVIDED TO ME AND I WANTED TO SPEAK TO HIM – AND HE SAID “NO.”.

THE GUARDS AND HIM TOLD ME THAT I HAD TO ANSWER THE QUESTIONS.

FOR ABOUT 30-60 MINUTES HE WAS ASKING ME GENERAL INTERNET QUESTIONS WHICH I ANSWERED. MANY OF HIS QUESTIONS I COULD NOT ANSWER AND TOLD HIM I COULD NOT REMEMBER OR DIDN’T HAVE FILES IN FRONT OF ME TO GIVE HIM A CORRECT ANSWER. AT THIS TIME.I WAS VERY HUNGRY AND WEAK SO I TOLD THE SERGEANT I WOULD LIKE LUNCH BECAUSE I WASNT FEELING GOOD. HE TOLD EVERYONE TO BREAK FOR LUNCH AND IT WOULD CONTINUE AFTER LUNCH.IT WAS ABOUT NOON WHEN WE TOOK OUR BREAK. I WENT BACK TO MY DORM AND ATE LUNCH QUICKLY AND CALLED MY COURT APPOINTED ATTORNEY WHICH I SPOKE TO HIS SECRETARY AND THEY TOLD ME WHEN I WAS CALLED BACK DO NOT ANSWER ANY QUESTION BECAUSE HALPERN DID NOT NOTIFY HIM ABOUT THIS DEPOSITION.I WENT BACK AROUND 2 PM WITH HALPERN AND THE OTHERS IN THE ROOM. HALPERN TOLD ME TO LOOK AROUND AND SEE IF I KNEW ANYONE IN THERE. I SAID NO THE PEOPLE I CAN REMEMBER THERE WAS HALPERN, SAUNDERS, AND-EVANS- THERE WERE ONE OR TWO OTHERS;AND I WASNT SURE IF IT WAS ECKSTEIN AND MAYBE SOMEONE ELSE. THEY WERE ALL LAUGHING AND MAKING COMMENTS WHEN I ANSWERED QUESTIONS ESPECIALLY THE MAJORITY OF QUESTIONS I SAID I DID NOT REMEMBER.AT THE AFTERNOON SESSION WITH HALPERN WHEN I TOLD HIM MY ATTORNEY SAID NOT TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS HE WAS FURIOUS AND ASKED A GUARD TO GET HIM AN OUTSIDE LINE SO HE COULD CALL HIM. HE CALLED ON SPEAKER PHONE IN FRONT OF ME SO EVERYONE COULD HEAR…

THE ATTORNEY TOLD HIM HE HAD NOT GOTTEN A CHANCE TO SPEAK TO ME AND THAT HE HAD A RIGHT TO DO SO BEFORE BEING QUESTIONED..

HALPERN ARGUED WITH HIM BUT THE ATTORNEY DIDN’T BUDGE AND HALPERN SAID HE WOULD HAVE ME SANCTIONED BY THE JUDGE IF I DIDNT ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.

THE ATTORNEY SAID, “DO WHAT YOU HAVE TO DO, BUT I ADVISED MY CLIENT TO SAY NOTHING. . AFTER HANGING UP, AND EVERYONE IN THE ROOM INCLUDING GUARDS HEARD THIS, HALPERN CONTINUED TO ASK QUESTIONS TO ME AND I TURNED AROUND IN MY SEAT IGNORING HIM AND ASKED THE SGT. GUARDS TO PLEASE TAKE ME BACK TO MY DORM I WAS DONE WITH QUESTIONS..

THE GUARDS IGNORED ME AND ALLOWED HALPERN TO CONTINUE HARASSING ME. EVEN THOUGH HIS DEPOSITION WAS ABOUT HIS CIVIL LAWSUIT I WAS SHOCKED WHEN HE WAS ASKING ME QUESTIONS ABOUT SEX WITH MY WIFE AND OTHER QUESTIONS THAT HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH HIS CIVIL SUIT BUT THE SGT, GUARDS WERE GETTING A KICK OUT OF SEEING ME IN PHYSICAL PAIN AS WELL AS HALPERN BEING IN MY FACE.

 
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 
All of that is posted at the investigativeblooger.com link provided above. None of it is new.
 
I cannot imagine something like that deposition, as described, happening in the county jail in Birmingham/Jefferson County, Alabama back when I practiced law there. I can imagine if something like that did happen back then and the public got wind of it, the deputies and deposing lawyer would be in deep doo doo.
 
Received this email yesterday from Dan Shramn, who has been on my email hit list for quite a while, and who has not been afraid to take on the local judiciary and State Attorney Office in court:
 
Sloan,
 
This guy [Krutko] wrote me years ago when I had the MarkKohl.com website and I have seen his postings different places. His stuff never was organized or with any proof. It was horrible trying to wade through it and I basicly ignored it after a point.
 
I had no idea of the rest of it until reading your site.
 
I tried to look up the case on the clerk’s site and nothing is found either civil or criminal. Any idea what is going on? It is really difficult to get a civil case sealed.
 
I have never heard of anyone being charged with criminal contempt in a civil case, much less put on probation. Failure to follow a civil judges order would be indirect civil contempt. There has to be a hearing to determine it is within the person’s power to carry out the court order and specific findings in a hearing. Something is not right here. It would appear that he didn’t have an attorney. If he was charged with criminal contempt, there would have to be a trial and he certainly would be entitled to the appointment of an attorney if he could not afford one.
 
I really would like to know what is going on.
 
My reply:
 
Hi, Dan.

Yeah, Krutko can go all over the place, which works against him, but it might be he is telling the truth about what happened to his boat, not only the theft claim, but what the City of Key West allegedly did to him re the boat, which, if true, set into motion all that followed. That history is included in today’s “Bubba Justice – Robert Krukto & Family” post, teaser for which sent separately to you a little while ago. Read my post from way back, link provided in today’s post by Krukto yesterday, to get the gist of his Duck Tours-ish claim against Key West.

There really are three cases now alleged:

1) The City of Key West drove the Krutkos out of their tour boat business.

2) The hotel marina then stole the Krutkos’ tour boat.3) Robert Krutko then was wronglfully extradited from Ohio for contempt of court in a civil lawsuit seeking injunctive relief against him for stuff he was blogging about the people he believed had screwed him and his family; then, he was put on probation; then, he was cited for probation violation over something he could do nothing about.

You are not the only person wondering about that file in the Clerk’s office, and perhaps later to day I will have input on that from someone who looked into it already, about which Krutko told me yesterday. I told him I wanted an email from the other people. The less I attribute to Krutko personally, of which other people have first-hand knowledge and he only second-hand, the less likelihood of getting him crosswise with his probation and the less likelihood of it being viewed as made up by him.

Later yesterday, received this from the lawyer representing the Krutkos in their lawsuit against the City of Key West, alleging the City drove the Krutkos out of business to help the Fury tour boat, in which Michael Halperon owned an interest:
 
Date: Thu, 22 Dec 2011 12:15:28 -0500
Subject: Re: A MUST READ
From:
wroe@roelaw.net
To: keysmyhome@hotmail.com
CC: wheezy9870@aol.com

Re: A MUST READ

Dear Mr. Bashinsky:

I am the attorney handling the suit against the City Of Key West. I went down to Key West to look over Mr. Krutko’s civil and criminal case file. While I was down there, I was able to see Mr. Krutko’s civil case file. However, I was not able to see Mr. Krutko’s criminal file even though he has a criminal case number. I asked someone in the clerk’s office about his criminal file and and no one could seem to locate the file. Finally, someone told me that the State Attorney’s office has Mr. Krutko’s criminal file. So I went over to the State Attorney’s office and asked to review Mr. Krutko’s criminal file. I was told by one of the Assistant State Attorney’s that there is no criminal case file.

Thank you

William J. Roe, Esq.

THE ROE LAW FIRM, LLC
2250 SW 3rd Ave. Suite 303
Miami, Florida 33129
Phone:
786-441-0366
Fax: 786-221-0286

 
Robert Krutko told me William Roe took over the case after the Cochran Law Firm made lots of promises but didn’t follow through.
 
On that same matter, this from Brett Sagenkahn, the retired police officer with whom I talked maybe two and a half years ago about the Krutko case. Brett was convinced back then that Robert Krutko was telling the truth about his boat being stolen, and was still convinced of it last night.
 
From: brett@yachtseeker.net
To: keysmyhome@hotmail.com
CC: wheezy9870@aol.com; wroe@roelaw.net
Subject: Indirect Criminal Contempt Case
Date: Thu, 22 Dec 2011 22:06:22 -0500

Dear Sloan,

Thank you for the call tonight. I do sincerely appreciate your dedication to seeking out truth.

With regards to the case about which we spoke, I would suggest that since you are in Key West, you might attempt to locate a criminal case file relative to the case number on file. As I explained, our trio was unsuccessful in locating an actual criminal file containing prosecutorial paperwork from The States Attorney’s Office or Clerk’s office, relative to the criminal case. The explanation we received on that day was that the States Attorney’s Office did not participate in the criminal action and my understanding from what I heard was that a criminal case number was obtained directly by the court.

Best of luck and best wishes for a happy, healthy holiday season.

Regards,

Brett

During Brett’s and my phone conversation, the court was Judge David Audlin.

Against Krutko, received this yesterday from Sherry Popham of Marathon:
 
From: sherry@marathonboatyard.com
To: sloanbashinsky@hotmail.com
Subject: RE: Bubba Justice – Robert Krukto & Family?
Date: Thu, 22 Dec 2011 16:08:57 -0500
Good Morning Sloan,

As someone significantly and unjustly impacted by this individual’s extensive online, telephone and very personal harassment, I would implore you to do more homework on this subject matter before arriving at any conclusions.

Talk to the MULTITUDES of people he personally attacked, the majority of which (like myself) had absolutely no involvement or inkling of why they were being harassed other than they crossed his path at the wrong time. Peruse the state and federal law enforcement reports about why his boat was arrested and ultimately sold at auction. Read the charges that he filed with the DBPR against myself and others and see that each of us were exonerated of any illegalities, ethical violations or even the appearance of the same.

It seems apparent that he came upon some hard times in his business. Through his own fault or others, I cannot say with authority. And, I do understand that, to some degree, he does not have the ability to make all of the libelous material he posted on the internet about me, my business and my family go away. However, this is why what he did (ostensibly as an angry response to his circumstances) was so heinous. Those lies will be out there for a LONG time. They still come up within a few pages of someone doing an internet search on me or my business for the purpose of exploring the reputation which we have worked hard to develop and which he has unjustly impugned.

Sincerely,

Sherry C. Popham

Marathon Boat Yard Marine Center

2055 Overseas Hwy

Marathon, FL Keys 33050

www.MarathonBoatYard.com

https://www.facebook.com/MarathonBoatYardMarineCenter

305.743.6341 Office

305.289.0751 Fax

I wrote back to Sherry, who has been on my email hit list for quite a while, and asked for details. Nothing back yet from her, but perhaps she hasn’t had time.
 
Regardless of what Robert Krukto did, or didn’t do, on the Internet, regardless of how the multitudes, or the few, feel about that, today you have read reports from people who believe what was done to Robert Krukto and to his family was heinous and that Robert has been unjustly impugned.
 
I usually can be reached at keysmyhome@hotmail.com.
 
As for the interesting recent development on the school district’s Audit & Finance Committee, as per this below from Larry Murray yesterday, when I first read in The Citizen of Duncan Matthewson appointing a charter school official to be on the AFC, I thought it was a bad idea fraught with conflict of interest. The AFC is supposed to be totally independent of the school district and the school board.
 
Date: Thu, 22 Dec 2011 19:22:37 -0800
From: citizenlarry007@yahoo.com
Subject: Hazel Hartman
To:
keysmyhome@hotmail.com
 
Sloan:
 
Rumor out of the Henriquez Building on the cusp of the Christmas holiday closure is that my replacement on the Audit and Finance Committee has resigned before attending her first meeting.
 
You may recall that Duncan Mathewson appointed Hazel Hartman to my seat. It seems that Ms. Hartman is the Budget Director of the BPK Charter School. One of the members of the AFC, I am told, pitched a fit over a perceived, if not obvious, conflict of interest. Had Ms. Hartman been a School District employee, she would have been precluded from the outset.
 
As an employee of a charter school, she ran afoul of the requirement that any member of the AFC “shall not have or hold any employment or contractual relationship that will create or give the appearance of a conflict of interest.” One would assume that Duncan Mathewson would have been aware of this requirement since it is part of the School Board’s Policies and Bylaws.
 
Considering Ms. Hartman’s employment, Policies and Bylaws notwithstanding, Mathewson was clearly pushing the envelope in asking her to serve and he put her in a compromising position. Ms. Hartman demonstrated equally poor judgement in accepting the appointment. Both are at fault, I should think, at her withdrawal.
 
My sources tell me that the Internal Auditor, Ken Gentile, discussed the matter of a possible conflict of interest with Ms. Hartman. In the course of that conversation, Mr. Gentile also purportedly described for Ms. Hartman the “extraordinary” demands on her time and energy that service on the AFC required. To that, Ms. Hartman replied that she was unaware that serving on the AFC would be so “arduous” and that she would be unable to contribute the necessary time and energy.
 
Consequently, the public explanation for Ms. Hartman’s resignation is not that her appointment created the appearance of a conflict of interest. Rather, the explanation for public consumption is that she simply did not have the time to do the job. Either way, the seat is empty at a particularly difficult time with the District’s finances.
 
It is now up to Duncan Mathewson to find a replacement for Ms. Hartman. Hopefully, out of the 73,000 people in Monroe County, he can find someone appropriate for the job without the baggage of the appearance of a conflict of interest. His announcement will have to await a meeting of the School Board as the appointment must be made “in open session.”
 
Larry
 
Larry Murray
Citizen Advocate
 
This is in The Citizen today:
 
Goodbye to committee, but it’s not farewell

I would like to thank the citizens of Monroe County for the opportunity to serve them on the School District Audit and Finance Committee. I did my best at all times to represent the public’s interest and to improve the financial activities of the district. Progress was made, but there is a long way to go before the district’s house is in order.
That I was the only member not reappointed came as no surprise.Early on, I was labeled by the district and the School Board as a troublemaker, someone who asked too many questions and raised too many issues. In recent months, the internal auditor has complained that my questions about district finances was occupying too much of his time. The result is that, in recent months, the internal auditor has simply ignored me.

Perhaps my greatest sin was to violate the Griffiths Rule: “Praise in public, but criticize in private.”I so upset board member Andy Griffiths by going to the press that he lead a movement to suspend the committee and require ethics training. Duncan Mathewson threatened to fire me if I did not stop publicizing the district’s failures, e.g. the botched contract with teachers with its $500,000-plus error.

Not continuing on the committee is a mixed blessing for me. While I would like to continue serving the public, my achievements in bringing real change to the district finances has been limited. “You can bring a horse to water, but …”It is my intention to continue involving myself in district finances, perhaps running for the School Board. Unconstrained by Sunshine Laws, I will be able to bring issues to the attention of all committee members, not required to go through “channels.”Uncooperative internal auditors can be circumvented by public records requests. Much remains to be done and I hope that I can be part of a community effort to effect real change in how the School District spends our tax dollars.

Larry Murray

Big Pine Key

Larry told me, when Duncan removed Larry from the AFC, Duncan told Larry the AFC required a lot of work and was stressfull, and urged Larry to run for the school board seat held by Duncan. Larry told me, whomever Duncan appoints to replace him on the AFC will serve a two-year term and cannot be removed meanwhile by Duncan or by anyone who succeeds him on the school board. We should hope Duncan gives more thought to his next choice to replace Larry on the AFC.

Bubba Justice – Robert Krukto & family?

Thursday, December 22nd, 2011

Received yesterday an email from Robert Krukto containing a copy of a letter asking website hosts to search their sites and remove therefrom anything he had posted there re various named individuals re theft of his tour boat in Key West. Also attached were ten return receipts for what appear to be ten websites. That seemed to substantiate Krukto’s claim that he tried to get taken down from the Internet what Judge David Audlin had told Krukto to take down when he put Krukto on probation.

Also emails from Krukto saying he did not post anything to the Internet about his alleged stolen boat case until after he and his family had gone back to Ohio in 2006, after losing their tour boat, having their Cudjoe Key home foreclosed, and going homeless and living in their car. On Krukto’s later extradition from Ohio back to Key West in 2009, consider this recent email from the Kruktos’ attorney to the Governor’s office.

 

THE ROE LAW FIRM, LLC
2250 SW 3RD AVE. STE. 303
MIAMI, FLORIDA 33129
PHONE: 786-441-0366 FAX: 786-221-0286

November 10, 2011


Via E-mail

Ms. Susan L. Smith

Criminal Justice Liaison
Executive Office of Governor Rick Scott
The Capitol, Suite 209
Tallahassee, FL 32399-0001

Re: ROBERT KRUTKO

 

Dear Ms. Smith:

My name is William Roe and I am a Florida attorney. Mr. Robert Krutko asked me to write to you about any information that I may have pertaining to his warrant.1

Mr. Krutko provided me a copy of the warrant that was issued in Ohio. Paragraph 2 of the warrant states the following:

The said fugitive stands CHARGED with the crime of Criminal Contempt of Court in the State of Florida. It has been represented to me that the said Fugitive was present in Monroe County, State of Florida at the time of the commission of said crime; and thereafter fled from the justice of that state, and has since taken refuge in the State of Ohio. I personally asked Mr. Krutko when was the last time we has in Monroe County, Florida and he informed me it was in June of 2006. He stated that the only time he was in Monroe County, Florida after 2006 was when he was extradited.

As you may know, “[t]he determination of whether an accused is a fugitive from justice depends only on whether he or she is charged with crime in the demanding state, was bodily present in the demanding state at the time of the offense, and thereafter departed from that state. 14 Fla.Jur 2d Criminal Law—Procedure § 316 citing Chase v. State, 93 Fla. 963, 113 So. 103, 54 A.L.R. 271 (1927); Kuney v. State, 88 Fla. 354, 102 So. 547 (1924); State v. Allen, 83 Fla. 655, 92 So. 155 (1922) (emphasis added).

Furthermore, after looking online on Monroe County Clerk of Court website, it shows that the Motion for Indirect Criminal Contempt was filed on or about September 17, 2009. Additionally, Mr. Krutko provided me a copy of the Notice of Hearing for the Motion for Indirect Criminal Contempt, and the Certificate of Service clearly provides that Mr. Krutko was residing in Ohio. See Notice of Hearing attached. Therefore, Mr. Krutko was never a fugitive from Justice because he was not bodily present in Florida.

I was not Mr. Krutko’s attorney during the time of his extradition.

I personally believe that Mr. Krutko was wrongfully extradited and I hope that your office investigate this matter.Please feel free to contact me if you have any further questions.

Warmest regards,


/s/ William J. Roe

William J. Roe, Esq.

On his probation violation, this yesterday from Krukto:

 
SLOAN,
 
I TOLD YOU WHY IM UNABLE TO COME DOWN THERE. ONE OTHER REASON IS THE JUDGE [David Audlin] IN THIS CASE FIRST SET MY BOND AFTER EXTRADITION AT 5K. I PAID AND WAS BONDED OUT. THE NEW WARRANT HAS A BOND SET MUCH HIGHER AT 20K. BEING DISABLED THEY KNOW I CANNOT POST A BOND OF THAT AMOUNT. BEING A RESIDENT FROM OUT OF STATE I HAVE TO PAY THE FULL BOND NOT THE 10%. I HAD TO BORROW THE 5K THE FIRST TIME AND NOBODY HAS EVEN THAT KIND OF MONEY NOW LET ALONE 20K.
 
ROBERT
 
On the first case before Judge Auldin, and his family’s tour boat, this long epistle yesterday from Krukto, which includes the text of emails from other people re the boat:
 
Sloan,
 
You are pretty much correct in what you stated. A civil case was filed [against him by Key West Attorney Michael Halpern, asking for injunctive relief because of what Kukto was posting onto the Internet about Halpern and his clients], I was not there for the hearing because i was never served. If you look on the Monroe County Clerks web site you will see on my case it says ” SUMMONS LOST” After not showing for the hearing [before Judge Audlin], shortly after the F.B.I. surrounded my house here in Ohio because a warrant was sent to the for -FUGATIVE FROM JUSTICE -FLED JURISDICTION- They were under the impression it was for some big wanted criminal. Once they determined it wasnt they washed their hands of it and the local police took over.Being as sick as i was i was appointed counsel to represent me when i got to key west. The attorney from miami representing me [in a civil case against the City of Key West over the boat] told me he had never seen a civil case with an extradition in his life and it was wrong. He told me if i took this to trial Judge Audlin would throw the book at me. Being scared and sick he told me the best thing to do would be to take the plea so i could get home to see my kids. Thats when the judge gave me 1 yr probation and 10 days to remove all internet postings i made the last 4 previous years against the individuals filing suit against me.  
 
http://goodmorningfloridakeys.com/?m=20091005

THE ABOVE LINK IS YOUR WRITEUP ABOUT OUR CURRENT SUIT AGAINST THE CITY OF KEY WEST.

 
[Most of that post is about the Kruktos' claim that the City of Key West ran the Kruktos out of business, so the Fury, in which Michael Halpern owned an interest, could get the the favorable boat slip used by the Krukto's boat, not entirely unlike what the City had done to Duck Tours, so Ed Swift's conch trains and trolleys would not have a competitor. The Kruktos' complaint against the city describes the genesis of all that came afterward, about which I have been writing lately re Robert Krukto.]

Dear Dennis [Ward],

It has been brought to my attention that about a year ago a boat was stolen in Key West which I believe is grand theft and should be brought to trial or at the very least an investigation should be done. In this particular case it seems that neither was done. That it was called a civil case. I’m sure I don’t have to tell you that stealing a boat is not a civil matter. It has caused great hardsh ip on the family that owned the boat. It was not just a boat for recreation but a boat that was used commercially to provide an income. The family that is the victim is from Ohio. This is the last thing that we need in the Keys is for justice not to be done. We rely on tourism down here and what we don’t want is for these beautiful islands to get a bad reputation that when something happens everyone just looks the other way. I truly am urging you to conduct an investigation into the matter. If you have any questions please feel free to contact me.

Thank you,

Kim Bagnell Thaler

Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate
Broker Associate
Cel . (305)393-2787
Direct . (305)289-6622
Office . (305)664-4470
Fax . (305)664-4111

Kim@KimBagnell.com

HERE IS THE U.S. NAVY EMPLOYEE WHOM IVE NEVER MET WHO WAS ON THE SCENE THE DAY MY BOAT WAS STOLEN AND WITTNESSED THE THIEVES STEALING AND HOTWIRING MY BOAT.

WHAT E SAYS IN HIS LETTER IS CONFIRMED BY THE FLORIDA WILDLIFE COMMISSION STATE POLICE ON THE SCENE. THEY WERE ALSO LIED TO AND TOLD THIS INDIVIDUAL WAS THE OWNER OF MY BOAT. AGAIN NO COURT ORDER TO GO AND TAKE A BOAT UNDER THE FALSE PRETENCES YOU OWN IT. IF YOUR DOING SOMETHING WITHIN THE LAW WHY LIE ?????

Mr. Krutko’s boat (who I have never met) had been anchored in Cudjoe Bay, broke anchor and was drifting towards my boat and dock. The phone number printed on the side of the boat was not a working phone number. I contacted the Coast Guard and the Marine Patrol/FWC. One o f the 2 agencies (I cant remember which) recognized the name of the boat and told me it was usually docked at the Ocean Key Resort and I should contact them. Both agencies stated if I towed the boat to deeper water to secure it I would then be held responsible if it broke anchor again. I called the Ocean Key House and was transferred to John Evans who was very excited I had found His boat. He told me a disgruntled  employee had disappeared along with the boat. I left work early and when I arrived home I believe there was a FWC boat, a Law Enforcement boat and a Sea Tow Inflatable near my dock. The two larger vessels “escorted”/ “sandwiched” the vessel in question to deeper water minutes before the vessel would have come in contact with mine. As they were reaching deeper water I saw another boat with a driver and passenger approaching the scene. One of the men boarded the vessel and eventually started the engines. He yelled to me He was John Evans and He told me to come down to the Ocean Key House for a free dinner on the resort as a reward for finding the boat. I told Him there was no need for the reward I was just happy He recovered His boat and there was no damage to my property. On 1/12/07 J ohn Evans contacted me again asking more information about the incident saying the FWC stated they were never on the scene. I said that was crazy and I had photo’s proving it. I burned a disc and gave it to John who then insisted my wife and I go and have a free dinner. We did go have a great meal on 1/31/07. All my photo’s have now been provided to John Evans, Robert krutko and Charles Tunnicliff (850 4879656) of the Dept. of Business and Professional Regulations.

V/R
Melvin J Herlehy
Engineering Technician
FEAD PWDKW
PO Box 9018 KW FL 33040
305 293 2566 office
305 797 1648 cell 305 293 2631 fax
melvin.herlehy@navy.mil

From: Kevin
To: dennisward@aol.com
Sent: Monday, December 22, 2008 1:44 PM
Subject: Key West nightmare

Dear Dennis

My name is Kevin McCarthy I own and operate Amelia River Cruises & Charters in Fernandina Beach, Florida. In the fall of 2006 my wife and I drove to Key West to look at20a few commercial tour boats that were for sale. We looked at a 45? 49 passenger U.S. Coast Guard Inspected vessel that was chained to the dock at the Ocean Key House Resort. The asking price was $110,000 the broker informed me that there were outstanding dock fees and that is why the vessel had been chained to the dock. I expressed an interest and told the broker that I would make an offer in a week or so. Two days latter the broker called to inform me that the vessel was to be auction off the very next morning at the Ocean Key House Resort and that the hotel had taken possession of the vessel for the delinquent dock fees and the starting bid would be $61,000. The next morning I called the Resort and spoke with the manager Mr. Steve Boswell I asked him if in fact the vessel was to be auctioned off that morning his response was yes and then he handed the phone to his attorney Allen Eckstein. I asked Mr. Eckstein if the Resort now owned the vessel and if there were any other outstanding leans on the vessel. Mr. Eckstein told me that the Resort did now own the vessel and that there were no other outstanding leans. I them called the broker to ask if he coul d attend the auction on my behalf, I authorized him to bid up to $71,000 plus a 10% broker fee for him. At 10:15 that morning I received a call form the broker that the boat was mine for $71,000. I received a bill of sale from attorney Eckstein and took possession of the vessel. After a month i n dry dock and with about $20,000 in repairs my wife and I were sailing our new tour boat from Marathon Key north to Amelia Island Florida. We stopped in Miami that first night and I received a phone call From Mr. Robert Krutko, Robert explained to me that I did not own the vessel and that it had been st olen from him. I then called Attorney Eckstein he assured me that the vessel was in fact mine and the everything had been done lawfully, My next call was to a Maritime Attorney in Miami I explained my situation to him, his first question to me was did the Resort arrest the vessel and was there a U.S. Marshal at the auction my answer was no. The Attorney then told me that I in fact could not own the vessel and that the transaction in his opinion was not done poperly. By this time we were on our way to Ft. Lauderdale and I had made arraignments to stop at First Performance Marina for some engine repair. Just as we were pulling in to the marina we were boarded by the U.S.Coast Guard and then the Broward County Sheriffs Department they looked at my bill of sale they both told me th at the bill of sale was not worth the paper it was written on. I then made arraignments with the marina to leave the boat there and we returned to north Florida that was the last time I saw the boat and I was out $91,000. I then hired an attorney in Jacksonville and after about a month of haggling the r esort did return my purchase price of=2 0$71,000 and the broker did return his 10% fee.

I am out at lest $20,000 and the hole ordeal has been a nightmare. I am convinced that the Ocean Key House  Resort ,Mr.Steve Boswell, Attorney Allen Eckstein and Mr. John Evens the young man that hot-wired and then removed the vessel from Cudjoe Bay and returned it back to the resort all participated in the Grand theft of this vessel. I am also convinced that had the Monroe County Sheriff’s Department the F.W.C and the States Attorney’s office in Key West had done there jobs I would not have had to endure this nightmare. Mr. Krutko and I do not have the financial were with all to go after this type of injustice and I am very disappointed in the way this has been handled by those governmental organization that are sworn to up hold the laws in this state.

Sincerely

Kevin McCarthy

Dear Mr. Ward,

I realize that you have not taken office yet, but I have become painfully aware that an injustice may h ave taken place approximately 18 month ago.

Mr. Robert Krutko of Columbus, OH, formerly of Cudjoe Key has contacted me via the internet to help him get a formal investigation of the circumstances leading to the theft of his 45? boat, the subsequent sale of same, and the reversal of that sale.

I am a long time resident of the Keys and love them dearly. Certainly this man’s claims of inside dealing, and poor law enforcement can be quelled by a proper investigation, which he claims never took place. Please make this case one of your first orders of business for the new year.

Sincerely,

Paula Nardone

NOTE- BEFORE DENNIS WARD WAS ELECTED I [Robert Krukto] SPOKE TO HIM BY E MAIL AND PHONE ASKING HIM TO HELP WHEN HE WAS ELECTED. HE TOLD ME IF HE WAS ELECTED HE WOULD LOOK INTO AND INVBESTIGATE MY CASE. I SPENT MANY HOURS PUSHING FOR HIM TO GET INTO OFFICE HOPING HE WOULD KEEP HIS PROMISE WHICH WAS NEVER DONE. I EVEN GOT AN INVITATION BY E MAIL TO HIS SWEARING IN CEREMONY BUT COULD NOT MAKE IT. I SUPPORTED A MAN AND PUSHED FOR HIM BEING ELECTED THINKING I WOULD GET HELP FROM HIM.

By Rod Sullivan

TrackBack (0)
In Florida, Does a Marina Have a Lien on a Boat which left the Marina without paying?
Category: General

Prior to 1978 in Florida, marinas had no liens on boats under Florida law, although they did have a maritime lien under general maritime law. In 1978 the Florida Legislature gave marina owners a possessory lien on boats at the marina in a statute which now is identified as Section 328.17 of Florida Statutes.

However, once a vessel leaves a marina, it loses its possessory lien. Florida lien law is then preempted by federal maritime law. See Bernier v. Broward Marine, Inc., 504 So. 2d 1379, 1381 (Fla. 4th DCA 1987). Then it is just like any other lien holder. To enforce its lien, it needs to arrest the boat in federal court and assert its lien there.

 

++++++++++++++++++

 

I did not ask Krukto who added the emphasis in the emails, but I imagine he did it. If Sullivan was correct, the Kruktos’ boat could not legally be gone after and taken back to Key West, even if the marina’s claim to a lien was accurate. Krukto tells an entirely different story about all of that next below. He also tells of threats he and his family received for claiming their boat was stolen and then trying do something about it. He described that yesterday in an email to me, as follows:

 
WHY WE MOVED THE BOAT.
 
WE BOUGHT BOAT AND BUSINESS JUNE 2006- WE WERE PROMISED A LEASE FROM STEVEN BOSWELL THE NEW MANAGER AT OCEAN KEY RESORT. STEVE SAID HE WAS MOVING HIS STUFF TO KEY WEST FROM CALIFORNIA AND WAS VERY BUSY JUST TAKING OVER THE HOTEL AND MOVING. HE SAID AS SOON AS HE GOT SETTLED IN A MONTH OR SO HE WOULD GET THE NEW LEASE TO US. HE DID SAY THE OLD OWNER HAD A LEASE FOR A COUPLE MONTHS OR SO AND SAID THE RENT WAS 3K I THINK IT WAS I WOULD HAVE TO TRY AND LOCATE OLD CHECKS ITS BEEN 5-6 YEARS BUT IM PRETTY SURE.
 
A COUPLE MONTHS WENT BY AND WE KEPT GETTING EXCUSES FOR NOT GETTING A LEASE. ABOUT THIS TIME IT WAS WELL RUMORED ON THE DOCKS THAT JOHN EVANS OWNER OF HYDRO THUNDER AND THE MAN THAT TOOK OUR BOAT WAS WANTING FURY IN OUR SPOT. WE DIDNT CONNECT THE NUMBERS AND THOUGHT IT WAS JUST RUMORS. A SHORT BIT LATER KEY WEST WAS HIT BY HURRICANES. THE SUNSET PIER BEHIND OCEAN KEY WAS PARTIALLY DESTROYED. OUR SLIP WAS STILL INTACT. WE WERE IN THE CITY MARINA AT THE TIME OF HURRICANES BECAUSE BOSWELL FORCED US TO MOVE ALL BOATS SO IT WOULDNT DAMMAGE THE HOTELS IF THE WAVES WERE BAD. AFTER THE HURRICANE WITH OUR SLIP STILL IN TACT BOSWELL SAID WE COULD RETURN BUT THERE WOULDNT BE MUCH BUSINESS BECASUE THE TOWN WAS HIT HARD. WE AGREED BUT DEMANDED A LEASE WHICH WE STILL DIDNT GET. WE WERE GOING TO LEAVE AT THAT POINT BUT BOSWELL GAVE US FREE TIME FOR THE LOW AMOUNT OF TOURISTS THAT WOULD BE COMING DOWN FOR A WHILE. WE NEVER GOT A LEASE AND WERE ABLE TO STAY THERE PER OUR AGREEMENT TIL THE END OF MAY 2006.
 
AT THAT TIME WITH THE CITY CUTTING OUR CAPACITY IN LESS THAN HALF, CODE ENFORCEMENT CONSTANTILY STANDING AT OUR BOOTH AS WE LOADED TRIPS TO MAKE SURE WE DIDNT GO OVER 24 WE WERE DOOMED FROM THE BEGINNING. WE MOVED OUR BOAT OUR IN MID AFTERNOON AND TOLD BOSWELL WE COULDNT OPERATE NO MORE WITH JUST 24 PASSENGERS INSTEAD OF 49 WE MOVED OUT. ALSO WE HAD A TICKET BOOTH BEHIND OUR BOAT WHERE WE SOLD T SHIRTS CAMERAS AND BOOKED TRIPS AND IT WAS DESTROYED IN THE HURRICANE . BOSWELL SAID THE CITY COME BY AND WANTED IT REMOVED AND WE WOULD NO LONGER HAVE A BOOTH TO SELL FROM. THIS ALSO HURT TREMENDIOUSLY. ALSO BOSWELL HAD A MEETING AND TOLD US THE CITY WANTED OUR ADVERTISING SMAILL BILLBOARD REMOVED FROM THE FROM OF OUR BOAT. THEY WERE TAKING EVERYTHING AWAY AND NO WAY WE COULD KEEP OPERATING AS CRIPPLED AS WE WERE. AFTER WE MOVED THE FURY WAS ALLLOWED TO TAKE OVER OUR SLIP WITH 2 BOATS AND 252 – 253 PASSENGERS WITH NO RESTRICTIONS. THEY WERE GIVEN THE RED CARPET. AFTER WE MOVED OUTR THE BOAT WAS STOLEN LATER THAT DAY OR THE NEXT DAY AND BROUGHT BACK TO OCEAN KEY RESORT WHERE THEY DISMANTLED AND TORE THE BOAT DOWN. THEY STRIPPED IT AND ITS IN THE SHERIFFS REPORT WHERE THE OFFICER ON THE SCENE WITTNESSED THE BOAT CHAINED UP AND BEING DISMANTLED.
 
NEXT QUESTION WAS THREATS.
 
AT OUR OLD OHIO HOUSE BEFORE REPOED BY THE BANK WE RECIEVED MANY CALLS SOME WERE 1 AFTER ANOTHER TELLING US WE WERE DEAD- QUIT COMPLAINING BITCH OR YOUR DEAD- ETC.
 
HERE ARE A COUPLE OF THE E MAILS WE RECIEVED

—–Original Message—–
From: Keywestkurt <
Keywestkurt@aol.com>
To: sale-630630665 <
sale-630630665@craigslist.org>
Sent: Fri, Apr 4, 2008 9:16 pm
 
NO MATTER HOW MANY DOLLARS WE HAVE WE GOT YOUR $$$, TAKE THAT YOU LITTLE BITCH, BECAUSE WE SAW YOU GUYS COMING, HEHEHEHEH
 
 
—–Original Message—–
From: Keywestkurt <
Keywestkurt@aol.com>
To: sale-630630665 <
sale-630630665@craigslist.org>
Sent: Fri, Apr 4, 2008 9:03 pm
 

WHO YOU CALLING BITCH, DO YOU THINK YOU ARE TALKING TO THAT HO YOU CALL YOUR WIFE, GIVE IT UP BOY, YOU AND YOUR FAMILY ARE REAL LOOSERS THAT ARE PROBALLY CONSTATLY BEING TARGETED BY PEOPLE, YOU ARE A TARGET FOR $$$, NOW JUST LIVE WITH IT OK, GO ON WITH YOUR PALTRY LITTLE EXISTANCE, LOOSER
 
Case # 100750652 Title Menacing
Report # 100750652.1 Subject 255 – Menacing
Location 1727 Ridgebury Dr
City Hilliard Zone 3
Precinct 15 District 152
Occurred 8/31/2010 2:04:00 AM Between N/A
Report Date 8/31/2010 4:16:44 AM    
Reported By Officer Fasone Badge 2217

Report Narrative

Victm #1 states that on the above listed date and time person(s) unknown threw a brick through his rear sliding glass door. Attached to the brick was a handwritten note threatening Victim #1 to drop a lawsuit or he was going to be a “dead-man”.
Offense #1
 
Offense Description   Completed
Aggravated Menacing   Y
 
 
Offense #2
 
Offense Description   Completed
Criminal Damaging/Endangering   Y
 
 
Offense #3
 
Offense Description   Completed
Intimidation _ victim, crime witness(13C)   Y
 
 
Victim #1
Individual
Name   Gender/Race/Age
Krutko, Robert M / W / 43
Address  
1727 Ridgebury Dr
Hilliard, OH 43026
 
 
No Arrestees Reported
Property Item #1
Door / Door Frame
Manufacturer Model
N/A N/A  
Description   Value
Rear sliding glass door $300.00
 
 
 
A BRICK WAS THROWN THROUGH OUR BACK SLIDING GLASS DOOR. I WAS DEAD ASLEEP UPSTAIRS BUT MY NEIGHBORS IMMEDIATELY HEARD THE CRASH AND CALLLED 911. I WOKE UP THE POLICE WAS HERE AND THEY TOLD US WE COULD NOT GO AROUND BACK TIL THEY WERE DONE. I SAW THE GLASS OF COURSE BUT NEVER GOT TO SEE THE NOTE BECAUSE THE POLICE WRAPPED IT UP IN AN EVIDENCE BAG. THE OFFICER ASKED ME IF I HAD ANY CASES GOING I TOLD HIM IN FLORIDA. HE TOLD ME WHAT THE NOTE SAID ATTACHED TO THE BRICK AS HE PUT IT IN HIS TRUNK BRICK AND ALL
 
AS HE WAS LEAVING HE TOLD ME TO WATCH MY BACK
 
LAST THREAT WE GOT..
 
WHEN I WAS JAILED IN KEY WEST I WAS VERY SICK. I WAS IN MEDICAL 24/7 BEING MONITORED. A FEW WEEKS OR SO WENT BY AND THE GUARD TOLD ME I WAS BEING MOVED TO GENERAL POPULATION. I WAS VERY SICK AND FELT SOMETHING WAS WRONG. AROUND 2-3 AM I WAS AWOKEN AND TOLD TO GET READY FOR GENERAL POPULATION. A GUARD COME AND GOT ME I WAS VERY WEAK. I WENT INTO THE DORM ASSIGNED TO ME AND A GUARD WAS THERE AT HIS DESK AND EVERYONE WAS ASLEEP. HE TOLD ME TO TAKE THE EMPTY BUNK AND GO TO BED. I KNEW SOMETHING WAS WRONG. THE NEXT MORNING EARLY WE GOT UP FOR BREAKFAST EARLY. I GOT MY TRAY AND WENT TO SIT DOWN. I COULDNT EAT MUCH AND WAS SHAKING BAD SO I WENT BACK UP FRONT WHERE THEY LEAVE A LARGE COOLER FOR JUICE REFILLS. WHILE THERE TWO MEN COME UP TO ME AS I WAS FILLING MY GLASS. THEY SAID-
 
ARE YOU THE INFAMOUS ROBERT KRUTKO POSTING STUFF ABOUT CERTAIN BOATINGBUSINESS ON THE INTERNET?
ARE YOU THE ONE BLOWING THE WHISTLE ??
 
I SAID IT DEPENDS WHOS ASKING??
 
( REMEMBER I WAS ONLY UP A SHORT BIT SO NOBODY KNEW I WAS THERE)
 
THEY SAID IT DIDNT MATTER…
 
A SHORT BIT LATER IN THE BACK OF THE DORM THE GUYS THAT APPROACHED ME AND ASKED ME THE QUESTIONS GOT 3-4 MORE GUYS TOGETHER AND STARTED SHOUTING
 
KRUTKO IS A DEAD MAN
IF KRUTKO GOES IN THE SHOWER HES NOT GOING TO COME OUT ALIVE
 
KRUTKOS AN INTERNET NARK
 
BY THIS TIME THE GUARD- AND I STILL REMEMBER HIS NAME KIP- HEARD WHAT WAS GOING ON AND AS APPROACHED THE DESK HE GAVE ME A PAPER AND TOLD ME TO FILL IT OUT ASKING FOR PROTECTIVE CUSTODY., I DID AND WAS ESCORTED OUT BY SEVERAL GUARDS.
 
SEVERAL WEEKS LATER THE GUARDS IN THE DORMS ROTATE DORMS AND KIP WAS OUR GUARD. HE APOLOGISED FOR WHAT HAPPENED AND TOLD ME AFTER I LEFT THE DORM TO PROTECTIVE CUSTODY HE WENT BACK AND TOLD THE GROUP OF GUYS THEY WERE COWARDS FOR THREATENING A MAN AND DOING IT BEHIND HIS BACK IN A GROUP. I THANKED HIM
 
OH YES AND WHEN GOING THROUGH MY PAPERWORK THE OTHER DAY I SAW THE COPY I BELIEVE HE HAD ME FILL OUT ( FOR PROTECTIVE CUSTODY)AND IT WAS SIGNED BY HIM.KIP

I wonder if I will receive threats, or if somebody will sue me and try to get me ordered by a judge to take this post down from my websites?

I usually can be reached at keysmyhome@hotmail.com.